School principal pleads guilty to seven counts of sexual activity with a student. She was 17.
April 26, 2008 - Herman Overcash, 54, principal of South Davidson High School was arrested Thursday and charged with tw
o counts of felony sexual activity with a student by a school administrator for a sexual relationship with a 17-year-old female student.
An investigation began after the sheriff's office received "a complaint from a third party," about the alleged incidents.
Overcash had been a teacher at Wallburg Elementary. He spent time as a physical education teacher at North Davidson Junior High, a teacher at Extended Day School, and a teacher and assistant principal at Ledford High School. He was suspended Wednesday from his position at South Davidson High School.
Full Name: Herman Keith Overcash
Arresting agency: Davidson County Sheriff's Office
GUILTY PLEA June 12 - Overcash pleaded guilty Thursday to seven counts of sexual activity with a student by an administrator. District Attorney Garry Frank says Overcash will serve six months jail time plus time already served. Overcash will also serve probation and will have to register as a sex offender. AND,
PLEA DETAILS June 13 - A fuller explanation of the plea.
- Overcash to serve an active sentence of two months for each charge, for a total of six months, with credit for time he has spent in jail since his arrest in April.
- A suspended sentence of 39 to 48 months ( three consecutive prison terms of 13 months to 16 months. )
- Five years on supervised probation after his active prison sentence.
- After his sentences are served, he will have to enroll in a sex offender program.
- Registration as a sex offender for 10 years.
Thursday, June 12, 2008
Denton, NORTH CAROLINA
Posted at
10:04 PM
Labels: Followup, Guilty, North Carolina, Principal, Student/Teacher Sex
Mason, OHIO
At first we thought he must have been a 20-something.
June 12, 2008 - Michael J. Crotty, a longtime assistant coach for the boys basketball program at Mason High School, was in court today in connection with a “beer pong” party at his home in January. He was charged with knowingly allowing underage persons to remain at his residence while possessing or consuming alcohol."
Crotty was photographed at the party playing a drinking game called “beer pong” with the teenagers. The incident was first brought to the attention of the school district by members of Citizens For Accountability and Results in Education, the newspaper describes as, "a citizen group frequently at odds with the school board and administration. " [TT - We like em already.]
In beer pong, participants bounce ping pong balls into cups containing beer and drink from the cup in which the ball lands. Crotty is not a teacher.
Columbus, GEORGIA
LAWSUIT
June 12, 2008 - When parents sued a school district after two girls were victims of a teacher, the Ledger-Enquirer asked for a copy of the letter from their attorney. The school district refused to release the claim for public record, arguing it was exempt from the Open Records Act, because it was a file similar to a medical record and contained information that would constitute an invasion of privacy.
The school district, represented by attorney Greg Ellington of the Hatcher-Stubbs firm, argued that the letter was exempt from the Open Records Act because it was a file “similar to a medical or veterinary record,” it contains information the release of which would constitute an invasion of privacy, disclosure of the letter would have a “chilling effect” on a channel of communication, and that a balancing test of public versus private interest would require nondisclosure.A judge disagreed and ordered the letter be released.
Muscogee Superior Court Judge Frank Jordan Jr. Has ordered the school district to disclose the letter sent by the victim's attorney, saying the public policy behind the Open Record's Act dictated the records be opened.The Letter The teacher is James Cypert Jr. TT - entry
---------------------- OPINION ----------------------
TT - Needless to say, we are all for lawsuits. Sometimes it is the only way to force a change of attitude on schools. Monetarily, it doesn't cost the taxpayer because all school districts are insured. (Where the insurance carrier will not pay the damages is when parents and taxpayers ought to scream, "Why not?"
We would feel a lot better if the settlements were public. If the school district settles, it will be because they acknowledge wrongdoing. It is in the public interest to know what that was.
Fairhope, ALABAMA
Punishable by up to 10 years in prison. Seven-year sentence suspended to three years probation.
June 12, 2008 - Andrew Newton, 46, a teacher at J. Larry Newton school, was sentenced to seven hears in prison - SUSPENDED - to three years of supervised probation.
In April, a jury convicted Newton, 46, of interfering with the parental custody of a former student who he said he was trying to help escape from a troubled home life. The jury acquitted Newton on charges of solicitation of a child by computer and enticing a child for immoral purposes.
CONVICTION Apil 12, 2008 - Several teachers testified during the four-day trial, and said that Newton was obligated to tell a school counselor if he suspected a student was being abused at home.
Interference with custody is a Class C felony, punishable by up to 10 years in prison. Baldwin County Assistant District Attorney Michael Pylant said prosecutors would seek the maximum sentence.
"He was obsessing on this kid, and his parents intervened," Pylant said. "And (Newton) tried to cut them out. He was very controlling over a 14-year-old boy he had no legal right to manipulate."The school - J. Larry Newton - is named for his uncle, a former Baldwin schools superintendent.
ADDITIONAL INFO From the Press-Register (June 13) - Not mentioned in this previous story, is that the teenager and his family testified.
The teen, his stepfather and mother testified that NewtonAnd a colleage of Newton's also testified - on Newton's behalf.
disrupted their lives. The teen moved to a northern Alabama city last year to escape the former teacher and the publicity, they said.
"We will never have that time back with him," his mother said.
Newton, his family and a former colleague, however, argued that the educator might have made missteps, but with good intentions. They said that Newton, a single father of children ages 19 and 13, has suffered enough by losing his livelihood and reputation.The district attorney said that Newton has expressed no remorse and essentially blames the crime on the victim.
After the sentencing, Newton said he was relieved that he didn't have to go to jail, but remains perplexed on how he ended up spending his father's 72nd birthday at a sentencing hearing.TT - the lowercase judge™ is Baldwin County Circuit Judge James H. Reid.
Posted at
3:58 PM
Labels: Alabama, Lowercase Judge, Outrageous, Sentenced
Washington, UTAH

June 12, 2008 - Gabriel E. Carlin, 34, a teacher at the East Harbor Christian Academy, pleaded guilty in March to two counts of third-degree attempted child sex abuse of an 11-year-old girl. 
During a court appearance, Carlin said that he kissed the young girl during a ride home and attempted to touch her chest and rear end. He will be sentenced in September.
The school is no longer in business.
SENTENCING DELAY October 21 - Sentencing was delayed for at least 90 days while Carlin recieves a court-ordered diagnostic evaluation.
"After the diagnostic, based on our agreement with the state, if the sentencing recommendation includes the possibility of prison time then he has the option to withdraw his (guilty) plea," said defense attorney Larry Meyers
Sentencing was set for Jan. 27, 2009.
Seattle, WASHINGTON
Pedophile made a career out of molesting children. He even mostested his own granddaughter.
April 19, 2008 - Phil McGee, 74, a physical education teacher, pleaded guilty to molesting four sisters he groomed for 10 years. from 2002 to 2006, beginning when the youngest was about 7 and the oldest was 15.
McGee, who had worked as a police chief in tiny Grand Coulee in E
astern Washington, ran a lively after-school ballroom dance class at B.F. Day, where he worked until 2002. Officials at the school reprimanded him for his "inappropriately close relationship" with the girls.
In 2005, McGee molested his own grandaughter. McGee was charged with first-degree child molestation. The girls' parents wanted to avoid a trial, so prosecutors let him plead guilty to a lower charge of fourth-degree assault for which he served two days in jail. He received a two-year community supervision sentence. He did not return to Rainier View Elementary School. He lost his teaching license in October 2006.
Full Name: Phil Frederick McGee
McGee taught at B.F. Day Elementary School and Rainier View Elementary Schools from 1994 until he was put on leave in April 2005 and fired in October 2006.
SENTENCED June 12 - McGee was sentenced to 16 and a half years in prison.
At his sentencing, McGee told the judge he realizes it's a life sentence.KiroTV: (June 12) McGee was arrested more than a year ago, but he skipped town and was a fugitive for months. He was finally taken into custody last year in Wyoming.
"You know what they say about old age. It doesn't last long," McGee told the judge. "Most likely, I'm not going to see the end of (the sentence) anyway."
Posted at
3:12 PM
Labels: Sentenced, Washington
Jackson, WISCONSIN
June 11, 2008 - Jeffery C. Baas, 40, principal of Jackson Elementary School, was arrested and charged with resisting an officer during a drunken driving arrest. The officer had to taser him twice. Additional officers were needed to handcuff him.
Baas was the former principal at Algonquin Elementary School in Brown Deer.
On June 11, 2005, just three days before he was offered the Jackson job, Baas and his live-in partner were arrested on suspicion of domestic violence battery after an incident at Baas’ home. Both men were listed as suspects and as victims in the incident.Baas had been placed on administrative leave pending a district investigation into the incident.
Under a plea agreement, the misdemeanor charge was dismissed in March 2006 after Baas successfully completed court-ordered batterer’s treatment and other conditions.
Full Name: Jeffery C. Baas
School website (be sure to see the picture)
School district: West Bend
Wednesday, June 11, 2008
Bigelow, ARKANSAS

June 11, 2008 -
John Tipton, a history teacher and coach at Bigelow High School, was arrested along with two other men, in an Internet sex sting where they expected to meet an underage girl.
Cleburne County Sheriff Marty Moss says when the men showed up for sex they were instead met by his deputies and police from Heber Springs.
Tipton is expected to appear in court July 7.
Arresting Agency: Cleburne County Sheriff
Kentfield, CALIFORNIA
Teacher who had a drunken sexual encounter with two Redwood High School teenagers last year was sentenced.
August 24, 2007 -
Amy Lee Kelly, 41, a teacher at Bacich Elementary School until the spring of 2006, was arrested and charged with having sex with two 15-year-old Redwood High School boys during a drunken encounter in Corte Madera.
Charged with two counts of lewd acts upon a child and one count of unlawful sexual intercourse, she pleaded not guilty.
The case stems from an incident on Oct. 20, 2006, when Kelly went to the home of a friend in Corte Madera. Kelly started drinking beer and red wine and became so intoxicated that her friend took her car keys away, according to an affidavit filed by Mitchell.Later, the daughter saw the other boy with Kelly. She also took pictures of the naked defendant with one of the boys. Kelly is divorced with two children. A preliminary is scheduled for September 6.
That evening, the 15-year-old Redwood High boys showed up at the house to visit the daughter of Kelly's friend. Both boys had consumed alcohol.
At some point during the visit, the daughter noticed that one of the boys was no longer downstairs. She went upstairs and saw the boy and Kelly engaging in sexual activity on her bed, the affidavit said.
OUTRAGEOUS Sept 7 - Outside of the courtroom, Kelly's attorney suggested she might have been the victim of a sexual assault by the boys. He isn't saying it's rape yet. A preliminary hearing is scheduled for Oct 31.
GUILTY PLEA - April 23, 2008 - At what was supposed to have been a preliminary hearing, Kelly pleaded guilty to one felony count of oral copulation of a person under 18 years old and one misdemeanor count of battery. Under the plea agreement, she will not have to register as a sex offender. She will be sentenced June 11.
She resigned the job in June 2006, several months before the sexual encounter.
SENTENCED (sorta) June 11 - Kelly was sentenced Wednesday to nine months in county jail - not prison. She was ordered to surrender to the jail on July 17, but she might be released shortly thereafter to serve her sentence under home detention.
She will be on supervised probation for five years. Kelly is barred from consuming alcohol or drugs during her probation and cannot visit with any minors except her own children. The judge also ordered Kelly to be examined for sexually transmitted diseases and report any positive results to the parents of the teens.
Kelly has two children. She could have faced up to three years in prison.
Posted at
10:17 PM
Labels: California, Sentenced
New Orleans, LOUISIANA
A federal probe into Care Unlimited alleges misuse of money that was supposed to have been directed at at-risk youth, education, a program to teach building and teaching skills to at-risk males, support of pregnant teenagers, and assistance to pregnant teenagers. Misuse Alleged
Now for the bad news.
That's just one of three charities associated with one family in Louisiana. Today the fourth member of the family was indicted. Family
Story of the latest indictment.
Posted at
5:37 PM
Labels: Corruption, Louisiana
New Bern, NORTH CAROLINA
CHARGES DISMISSED
April 30, 2008 - Philip Beeson, 53, an East Forsyth High School teacher, faces charges of assault on a female in his new school district.
The Winston-Salem Journal (Apr 30) reported more on the prior accusations.
In Forsyth County, Beeson resigned from his position as a teacher and assistant football coach at East Forsyth after an incident reported in November 1998 that involved six teachers at the school. Beeson was suspended without pay when the allegations surfaced.
One of the teachers, Douglas Shields, was accused of videotaping himself having sex with two female students and showing the tapes to others. In 2001, Shields pleaded guilty to one count of disseminating obscene materials and one count of third-degree sexual exploitation of a minor.
School officials said at the time that Beeson knew about Shields' conduct and failed to report it.
TT - Parents complained in May about the delay in addressing student complaints.
June 11 - CHARGES DISMISSED
Two misdemeanor charges of assault on female students filed by police against a New Bern High School teacher and coach were dismissed Wednesday in Craven County District court.
The teacher, Phillip Beeson, was freed of the charges after two teenage girls in the case had their attorney, Michael Mills, request that their subpoenas be quashed.
One girl's mother and one girl's father testified that neither family wanted to talk to police or press criminal charges against Beeson. Both parents said they didn't think Beeson had assaulted their daughters.
Posted at
4:14 PM
Labels: Charges Dismissed, North Carolina, OOI
Chickamauga , GEORGIA
What can you say?
June 11, 2008 - Tonya Craft, 36, a kindergarten teacher at Chickamauga Elementary School, was arrested, charged with child molestation and aggravated sexual battery
against three female students at the school.
Craft is charged with four counts of child molestation and one count of aggravated sexual battery against a child, Catoosa Sheriff Phil Summers said.
Full Name: Tonya Henke Craft
NewsChannel9: (June 11) The incident report also states there's at least one other victim and one other suspect. That suspect is underage, and police are investigating the possibility that the suspect is a victim as well.
WDEF ch 12: (June 11) A Ringgold mother filed the complaint against Craft. The woman's daughter told her Craft and another juvenile molested her at Craft's home in Chickamauga.
WRCB ch 3: (June 11) The victims range in age from seven to eight years old.
------------------------
TT - If you think women aren't capable of sexual abuse of small children, you might want to read about Tabatha Adams, a second grade teacher in Kansas who, along with the ex-husband of another teacher, molested an 8-year-old relative. Adams was sentenced life in prison with no possibility of parole for 25 years. She and the Nebraska man still face child pornography charges. Noble is still facing charges of sexual assault.
------------------------
LAWYER'S VIEWPOINT June 13 - The lawyer for Craft criticized a prepared statement issued by Catoosa County Sheriff Phil Summers on Thursday. The items of contention are whether Craft declined to be interviewed or not, and whether she agreed to take a polygraph test, or not, and a date in the arrest warrant.
The lawyer also said that Craft and the mother making the charges were friends in the past and the children, "They were children who were friends of her (Craft’s) daughter of similar age."
-----------
Town name misspelled. We apologize.
FIRED August 15 - Superintendent Melody Day recommended the dismissal. The school board voted to uphold Tonya Craft's termination at a special called meeting Friday afternoon. Craft is now a former kindergarten teacher at Chickamauga elementary. According to Craft's bond, she isn't allowed around children under the age of 18. In fact the only time she can be around children is at a family reunion. With that in mind the board had no choice but to let her go.School Board Vice Chairman Billy Ellis says had they not fired Craft they would have to keep suspending her every sixty days until she was found innocent or guilty.
Cincinnati, OHIO
Headline: "Ex-teacher indicted for affair"
Headline: "Ex-teacher admits affair with student"
- Cincinnati Enquirer
INDICTED Dec 10, 2007 -
Michael T. McKinney, 25, a social studies for one year at Arlington Heights Academy , *** was indicted on three counts of sexual battery for a sexual relationship with an 18-year-old student last spring.
His attorney says the charges are unjustified because the student was an
emancipated adult, taking courses at Cincinnati State at the time of the relationship. The grand jury indicted him because Ohio’s sexual battery statutes make it a crime for a teacher to have sexual contact with a student enrolled at the school where the teacher is employed, regardless of that student’s age.
McKinney resigned last May, citing a desire to go to law school.
*** Arlington Heights Academy is an alternative high school for at-risk students
GUILTY PLEA June 11, 2008 - McKinney pleaded guilty to one count of attempted gross sexual imposition, a crime with a maximum punishment of 12 months in jail. The prosecutor said he’ll probably get probation. He will have to to register as a sex offender for 15 years.
McKinney’s attorneys objected to the sexual offender registration, in part because McKinney is in law school and wants to be an attorney. Katie Pridemore, the assistant prosecutor who negotiated the plea deal retorted that McKinney should be listed as sexual offender, saying that if he did not adhere to professional boundaries as a teacher, he’ll have even more boundaries to comply with as a lawyer.
“He preyed on somebody who was subordinate to him. That’s somebody you keep an eye on,” she said.
The student was 18 at the time, living on her own and taking college courses. However, she was still enrolled in the high school. Ohio laws prohibit teachers, coaches and other adults in authority from having sex with or molesting children enrolled in their school. The law does not make an exception if a student is 18 or has enough credits to graduate
He will be sentenced July 2.
Posted at
2:21 PM
Labels: Guilty, Ohio, Student/Teacher Sex
Taft, CALIFORNIA
Taft College teacher in jail on second-degree murder charge.
June 11, 2008 - A judge has refused to reduce the bail of James Wyatt, 60, a Taft College teacher accused of tying up his long-time girlfriend who later died from suffocation.
Opposing a reduction in the bail for $1 million to $100,000, Kern County prosecutor David Wilson argued that noting that Wyatt and his co-defendant, Justin Mark Ennis, 21, disagree significantly about what happened that day. The co-defendant Wyatt had prior arrests related to similar behavior.
Wyatt’s next hearing is scheduled for June 17.
Full Name: James Arthur Wyatt
May 22 - Suspects' stories differ on tied-up woman's demise
Taft College teacher James Arthur Wyatt gave a harrowing account to police about how his longtime girlfriend was tied up and suffocated to death, but police noted that Wyatt didn’t seem upset or troubled by what happened to her.Wyatt dated the victim for off and on for 18 years and she lived with him for the past four years. Wyatt used to date Ennis’ mother and Ennis has become a friend. [ TT -The newspaper didn't put "friend" in quotes, but the relationship is distinctly weird. The story reads like a first-person account of the evening. And the reporter wasn't there.]
---------------------- OPINION ----------------------
TT - The trial promises to be as surreal as the trial and conviction of Vincent Brothers, the Bakersfield vice-principal who murdered his wife, Joanie Harper, age 39, their three children, (Marques, age 4; Lyndsey, age 2; Marshall, age 6 weeks) and his mother-in-law, Ernestine Harper, 70. That story never made national headlines.
In Bakersfield, the news with teachers isn't good even when they're sentenced. But that is, we suspect, due to the attitude of local papers.
Links in opinion area are internal.
Posted at
1:16 PM
Labels: California, Murder
Amite, LOUISIANA
Another lowercase judge™ in the news with the Always Clueless Lawyers making Asses of themselves.
June 11, 2008 - U.S. District judge Stanwood Duval Jr. said he has drafted a ruling that favors the ACLU Board its lawsuit over a teacher’s prayer during a public high school’s graduation. It is the one of seven cases the ACLU has filed against the same Louisiana school district.
But the judge agreed to wait until at least June 28 to issue that opinion so a settlement could be negotiated, including an agreement for the school board to pay for the ACLU’s attorneys fees, court records show.AND,
The case was the sixth of seven lawsuits that the ACLU of Louisiana has filed against the Tangipahoa Parish School Board since 1994, according to ACLU attorney Katie Schwartzmann. The ACLU also has sued the school board over prayers in the classrooms, at school board meetings and at footbal l games and over the distribution of Bibles on school property.School board attorney Christopher Moody suggested that the ACLU is unfairly singling out Tangipahoa Parish because most, if not all, of its cases against the school board are based on complaints from the same family, whose names aren’t identified in court papers
The teacher was filling in for an absent student when he gave the invocation and remarks were not prepared.
---------------------- OPINION ----------------------
TT - Coercing the school district to pay the ACLU fees is lowercase judge™ U.S. District judge Stanwood Duval Jr.. Wikipedia entry
WWLT said Bobby Jindal's campaign literature referred to Duval as a 'left-wing' jurist" without actually naming Duval. Jindal was elected Governor of Louisiana. And that's kinda remarkable considering Duval's rulings on Katrina.
(We haven't actually copyrighted lowercase judge, but lowercase judges are undeserving of the honorific capitalization of their title. They do not honor the law. )
Posted at
12:47 PM
Labels: Louisiana, Lowercase Judge
RANT OF THE DAY
RANT OF THE DAY
Compare this coverage of a "disgraced" teacher in New Zealand released on early probation with media coverage in the U.S. on parole releases of teachers in this country.
Continued here.
Gary, INDIANA
Another Poverty Pit school district.
June 11, 2008 - Liduvina Espinosa, 26, a Lake Ridge Schools substitute teacher, was arrested on charges of intimidation and battery after a 16-year-old girl and her father said the woman assaulted them with pepper spray, then waved a knife around threatening to kill them because she believed the teen had egged her car.
Espinoza denied being in the driveway, but police found her shoe on the property. Police also recovered a knife and pepper spray.
---------------------
-------------------- RESEARCH --------------------
WE FOUND: Lake Ridge School District is rated 3 (with 10 being the highest) at GreatSchools.net There are 2251 students in 5 schools in the district. While the total spending in the state averages $8,216 per student, this district spends $10,932. Some 66% of the students in the district are eligible for free lunch.
TT Opinion: Many of the districts with the poorest scores and high poverty rates get extra funding that doesn't seem to make a lot of difference. In fact, you might argue that the money might serve as an incentive to achieve poor results if only for the extra bucks. If it wasn't for the the requirements of the No Child Left Behind Act, that requires states to act on schools that repeatedly fail to teach, it's doubtful that the worst states would intervene in such schools.
The single high school in this district rates a 2 (with 10 being the highest) at GreatSchools. School data from the Indiana Department of Education is compiled in snapshot profiles of schools in the city of Gary and school districts. Calumet High School here. NCLB report.
The school district serves students within the unincorporated sections of the Calumet Township and portions of Gary. Also from Wikipedia:
The city of Gary has had a checkered history when it comes to education. As a result, test scores have fallen well below the national average of late. In response, multiple charter schools have been founded throughout the city as an alternative to the public schools. Since that time student performance has improved and the Gary Community School Corporation has built new elementary schools.ONLINE RESOURCE: Find a snapshot of any school in Indiana by name or number, school district, or city. Here
Posted at
9:10 AM
Labels: Arrested, Followup, Indiana, Online Resource
San Jose, CALIFORNIA
The lowercase judge™ ruled that because Hunt had demonstrated remorse and a will to turn his life around, including attending counseling, he did not send him to state prison as proscribed by law.
The lowercase judge™ also ruled that he would not to register Hunt as a sex offender, which would have restricted where he could live and work for the rest of his life, because of his efforts at rehabilitation
May 24, 2007 - Robb Hunt, 30, a student teacher at Lynbrook High from 2005-2006, was arrested, accused of having sex with a minor. Hunt currently teaches at Homestead High School in Cupertino.
Detectives believe there may be additional victims in other incidents.
Full Name: Robb Arlon Hunt
Anyone with information on this case or other incidents is urged to call Detective Patricia Bowers of the San Jose Police Department's Child Exploitation Detail at (408) 277-4102. Persons wishing to remain anonymous may call Crime Stoppers at (408) 947-STOP.
TT - The San Jose Police Department has online News Releases, but they are not current.
May 25 - Poster at NBC11 on the arrest:
Mr. Hunt is the best teacher Ive had in a long time. It is an unbeleivable act to accus such a good teacher of. It makes our entire class upset this had to leak out for people enjoyment. If Hunt was guilty, although highly unlikely, his life is now ruined by the medias need for scandal, this should haave been a private matter between Hunt. his students and family.SENTENCED (SORTA) June 11, 2008 - Hunt pleaded no contest in February to four felony counts of sexual acts with a minor and one misdemeanor count of child annoyance.
He was sentenced Tuesday to one year in Santa Clara County Jail - not prison - and five years of probation for having a sexual relationship with a 17-year-old Lynbrook High School student.
Lowercase judge™ Kenneth Barnum ruled that because Hunt had demonstrated remorse and a will to turn his life around, including attending counseling, he did not send him to state prison as proscribed by law.
Barnum also decided not to register Hunt as a sex offender, which would have restricted where he could live and work for the rest of his life, because of his efforts at rehabilitation.
The Santa Clara County District Attorney's Office had pushed hard for registration. Hunt is 30-years-old.
TT- How come the guilty get to appeal their sentences but the victims do not get to appeal those lax sentences by lowercase judges™ who would rather play social worker than uphold the provisions of the law?
A lowercase judge™ doesn't deserve the honorific capitalization of their title. They bring no honor to the law.
Posted at
8:39 AM
Labels: California, Lowercase Judge, Sentenced
Teacher Licenses in Nevada
It’s been nearly two years since a legislative audit criticized the Nevada Education Department for taking too long to revoke the teaching licenses of criminals.June 11, 2008 - The Las Vegas Sun is following up on a 2006 story on a legislative audit of state Department of Education problems in tracking teacher licenses. On Saturday the state Board of Education will consider revoking the licenses of three teachers convicted and sentenced for possession of child pornography. Two of them are already out of prison. There is still only one full-time staff member assigned to to monitor teachers facing potential discipline. And it still takes nearly two years to revoke a teachers license.
But officials are still taking up to 21 months to get the job done.
BACKGROUND Oct 10, 2006 - A 2006 audit by the Legislative Counsel Bureau uncovered a lack of policies and procedures to track criminal cases involving educators. State education officials said at that time that they often learned of teacher arrests from newspaper articles. One person was employed to monitor teachers licenses.
Keith Rheault, Nevada's superintendent of public instruction on licensing problems.
Ten years ago, when Rheault first began working with the licensing department, about 20 FBI reports came back with "hits," which indicate either a criminal history or red flags that require more investigation by her. That number is now in the hundreds annually.In 2005, the state Board of Education revoked four teachers' licenses, three for sex-related offenses.
TT - You might notice that all three teachers whose licenses will be considered on Saturday were in possession of child pornography.
TT entry for Carl Leiner
TT entry for Mark Zana
Moreno Valley, California
An attorney for the Commission on Teacher Credentialing said those whose credentials are revoked by the commission can apply for reinstatement a year after the revocation.
June 10, 2008 - The state Commission on Teacher Credentialing last week revoked Gerald Arterberry's teaching certification documents. Arterberry was the substitute teacher in the Moreno Valley Unified School District whose 22-year-old brother impersonated him in a classroom for three days at a middle school.
Issac Arterberry was arrested at Landmark Middle School on Jan. 26, 2007, and later was convicted of a misdemeanor for impersonating another person and sentenced to 20 days in jail.
Gerald Arterberry was not arrested or charged with any crime.
Substitute teachers in the district must now show photo ID when reporting for work.
Posted at
12:12 AM
Labels: California, License Revoked
Tuesday, June 10, 2008
Phoenix, ARIZONA
Chancellor Rufus Glasper criticized Todd for not providing hospital personnel with Ziegler's identification. She was an unidentified body in the morgue.
June 8, 2008 - When 19-year-old Andrea Ziegler died after she was found comatose on the floor of her professor's home, her parents hired a private detective. The investigator said that
four former PVCC students accuse [a Paradise Valley Community College professor] of having sexual relations with them. Only one of them formally documented it with police and the college.June 10 - The District fired Todd.
A letter from the school reveals that they made PVCC professor, Michael Todd take an on-line sexual harassment course in 2002. Todd was also warned to keep students out of his home, but that's exactly where Andria Ziegler was found passed out in April.
A community college professor has been fired after one of his students died at the professor's home of an accidental cocaine overdose.East Valley Tribune (June 10) - The board voted unanimously (5-0) to fire Michael Todd.
Michael Todd, 51, who taught at Paradise Valley Community College for eight years, was never a suspect in Andria Ziegler's death.
But the governing board of the Maricopa County Community College District voted Tuesday to fire him anyway. The district said Todd violated professional standards and the college's sexual harassment policy that prohibits "amorous relationships" with students.
MCCCD Chancellor Rufus Glasper criticized Todd for not providing hospital personnel with Ziegler's identification.Ziegler’s parents had notified authorities about 4:17 p.m. on Monday to report her missing, and started circulating fliers with her picture on them.
Instead, when hospital personnel in the emergency room told Todd and his neighbor that Ziegler had died, Todd said "I gotta get out of here" and went to his attorney's office, according to a police report.
Glasper also criticized Todd for not informing his supervisors of the incident.
Phoenix police then got involved after they became aware of an unidentified woman’s body at the Maricopa County Medical Examiner’s Office and connected them.
Todd was a psychology professor. Ziegler was most recently in his abnormal psychology class.
Trenton, NORTH CAROLINA
June 10, 2008 - Shebana Rajput 35, a Jones Senior High School physical science teacher, faces nine charges relating to a two-month sexual relationship she had with a 17-year-old student. The charges are: eight counts of sexual activity with a student and one count of sex offense with a student. [No indication if it is a male or female student.]
She was arr
ested Monday. According to a news release, Jones County authorities contacted the Lenoir County Sheriff's Office May 23 about an investigation of a sexual assault by a teacher with a student.
June 11 - An update from the paper.
On Wednesday, Kathleen Tanner, attorney for the Jones County Board of Education, told the Free Press that Ms. Rajput resigned from her job on May 21st. She also stated that Rajput was suspended in May, prior to her resignation. Tanner said that details of the suspension could not be released.The student is male.
June 11 - Rajput resigned May 21 shortly before police took over the investigation.
Posted at
11:04 PM
Labels: Arrested, Followup, North Carolina, Student/Teacher Sex
Norton Shores, MICHIGAN
The only substitutes we had in high school talked about their cats or how grateful we should be to get a good education. We bet this woman would have a show-and-tell story that would keep your interest.

Feb 21, 2008 - Tamara Poole, 37, a substitute teacher at Mona Shores High School, was arrested, accused of entering homes in what appears to be an effort to steal prescription drugs.
This is the second time Poole is accused of home invasion. She was recently charged in Ottawa County and posted bond.
Feb 22 - Grand Haven Tribune: Substitutes are provided by a contract firm.
Ottawa County court records show Poole was arrested at least three times. However, two previous cases were dismissed due to "mental issues," which were being dealt with through therapy and drug counseling and rehabilitation, court records stated.Feb 23 - Wood8tv: In court records reviewed by 24 Hour News 8, it was discovered Poole was bound over for trial three months ago on the same kind of charge. She's currently on bond on that case, and faces a July trial. Yet she somehow managed to find work as a substitute teacher.
Poole has a pending second-degree home invasion charge in Ottawa County, which is scheduled for trial in July. The charge is connected to a November 2007 incident in a Grand Haven home.
Drugs cost Poole her marriage and custody of her three children. Her husband filed for divorce in 2004 and gained full custody. In order to see them, she has had to submit to regular drug tests and get treatment. Off-camera, Poole's ex-husband told 24 Hour News 8 his main regret is that authorities were not tough enough in the beginning.
ARRAIGNED Feb 23 - After being arraigned, Poole's bond was increased to $100,000. A preliminary examination was set for March 6.
SENTENCED June 10 - Poole was sentenced Tuesday to two to 15 years in prison for second-degree home invasion and a concurrent one year for attempted second-degree home invasion in a separate case. She pleaded guilty May 13.
Muskegon County Circuit lowercase judge William C. Marietti declared he had no objection to Department of Corrections boot camp if the department finds Poole eligible. That could shorten her prison time.
TT - . Let's see some drug-crazed man get that sentence for wantonly entering homes. Or this,
Great Bozo comment about drugs to give in a courtroom in a case that will have the rapt interest of every student in that high school.Marietti stressed to her that her actions rose above the level of mere drug possession, which he called a "victimless crime."
"You have taken victims," Marietti said. "We can't tolerate in this community this type of behavior. This is a terrifying activity ... to have someone in their home. That's their space...."You have so much to offer, and that's just what's so tragic about the whole drug scene," Marietti said.
Toledo, OHIO
June 10, 2008 - When police in California started looking for a sex offender last week, they found him working - at a Toledo parish and school.
William Werner, 60, was convicted in 1989 of sex crimes against a 13-year-old girl. Released 10 years later, he then came to Toledo. He began working for St. Joan of Arc Parish five years ago as a part-time cleaner. He's in jail now for failing to inform authorities of his whereabouts.
Posted at
10:13 PM
Labels: Ohio, Sex Offender
Teacher Discipline
Sometimes you have to take a principled stand.
June 10, 2008 - New Jersey Education Commissioner Lucille Davy has ruled that a former Atlantic City teacher's conviction on child-abuse charges disqualifies her from any work within the district. The decision disagrees with an initial finding by an administrative law judge.
In 1998, the teacher, Nina L. Chavis, pleaded guilty to whipping her 9-year-old son with a plastic jump rope because he lied about his homework. She was sentenced to two years of probation in 1999, but stayed employed with the district.
That was until the Department of Education found out about it in April 2007 and notified Chavis that it would petition to disqualify her for the position at Texas Avenue School.TT - "The decision disagrees with an initial finding by an administrative law judge."
Chavis resigned May 9, 2007. On June 26, 2007, the Atlantic City Board of Education appointed her as Parent Center coordinator, effective July 1, 2007. But the Department of Education had problems with that as well.
Chavis no longer works in the district, according to Superintendent Fredrick Nickles.
"We severed that relationship earlier this year after the Department of Education told us we had to," he said Monday night.
The implication of that single sentence is best understood if you know how little weight your school district or state Department of Education has in firing or revoking a teacher's license. This 2007 case demonstrates the Ping Pong Process that is involved in disciplining a teacher. With the final decision made by people you never, ever elected.
You can do a search for "revocation teacher" or "school board" or "school" here if you want the aggravation. Trust us, you'll be frustrated.
Posted at
4:07 PM
Labels: New Jersey
Clarksville, TENNESSEE
Comment on his latest sentence : "You know how pathetic the justice system here is when I was actually happy he at least got some jail time. I was really expecting the system to be entirely suspended."
May 21, 2007 - Bryan Farmer, a Northeast High School teacher and basketball coach, was arrested in 2006 and charged with statutory rape for allegedly having sex with a 16-year-old female. Four months later, he was indicted on the previous charge with three more counts of statutory rape and 10 counts of sexual battery by an authority figure. In total, 18 counts of sexual battery.
His jury trial is expected to begin today with jury selection. Farmer is also being sued by another former student.
The Leaf Chronicle: "Farmer was indicted on a total of 18 charges with three victims, which include four counts of statutory rape and 14 counts of sexual battery by an authority figure.
However, the court decided in a separate trial last week to sever the counts." This trial is on eight counts for one victim.
Full Name: Bryan Dale Farmer
GUILTY VERDICT May 24 - The jury found Farmer guilty of one count of sexual battery but acquitted him of the charge of statutory rape. Farmer is scheduled to be sentenced on July 3. No date yet for any other trial. WKRN reports that Farmer had been teaching at Sycamore High School in Cheatham County when he was arrested in the latest case. He was fired from Cheatham County school system a year ago.
Update May 26 - This comment was posted at the Tennessean.
FYI: He has 2 more upcoming trials accused of the same thing with students from Northeast High School in Montgomery County. He was also investigated for the same thing in the year 2000 and 2001 at the school where he taught in Franklin County. Luckily for him there, the school was nice enough to do their own investigation before police were involved. It might have helped that he was a local basketball star there as well as having a father who worked for the school system. This man is a sexual predator and needs to be put away, he has gotten away with this behavior for way too long.SENTENCED July 6 - Farmer was sentenced to 60 days in prison, three years probation and 350 hours of community service. He still faces two more trials as well as a civil lawsuit.
July 20 - Farmer was supposed to turn himself in today but he failed to do so.
July 21 - Farmer reported to jail. His next trial is scheduled for Nov 28.
MOTION DENIED July 30 - A judge denied a motion for a new trial.
NO CONTEST PLEA Nov 26 - Farmer pleaded no contest to three counts of statutory rape. All the other charges against him connected to the case were dismissed. The state dropped six counts of sexual battery by an authority figure in this case and one count of the same offense in a third case.
He will be sentenced in Feb 28. He has lost his license to teach in Tennessee.
SENTENCING DELAYED Feb 28 - Sentencing has been delayed until June 6. Opposing attorneys agreed to the request pending the outcome of Farmer's appeal from his his first trial last May. Circuit Court Judge John Gasaway was hesitant to grant the request as he said the disposition could take up to a year. Farmer has not served the 60 day sentence.
SENTENCING HEARING June 6 - The father of the victim testified about the effect on his daughter. Farmer asked the judge to give him the opportunity to move on with his life and be a good father to his 5-month-old son in Alabama and marry the mother of his child. The fact that Farmer said it wasn't all his fault, but he didn't blame the victim for what happened, led the assistant district attorney to conclude Farmer showed no remorse for his actions.
Farmer is a registered sex offender in Tennessee. Farmer, who lost his Tennessee teaching license, said he doesn't want to ever teach again, but would like to coach one day.
SENTENCED (Sorta) June 10 - Farmer was sentenced to 120 days in jail - not prison - and two years of probation. Farmer must begin his 120 day jail sentence on July 10.
SENTENCE UPHELD August 19 - The Court of Criminal Appeals upheld the courts judgment in the case. Farmer appealed the case to the court of appeals stating the evidence was insufficient to sustain his conviction because he did not use his supervisory power over the victim to accomplish a sexual act and the court erred by not granting him full probation.
They also said he was not "entitled to probation as a matter of law," and the court was not wrong in denying Farmer probation due to a "questionable potential for rehabilitation based on both his denial of guilt and his previous resignation from employment due to a an inappropriate relationship with a student.TT - Guess he won't be able to 'just move on." At least not for 60 days.
"The court did not err when it determined a sentence other than full probation would provide an effective deterrent to others likely to commit similar crimes."
Tennessee is not known for robust sentencing of teachers who have sex with students.
Posted at
3:57 PM
Labels: Sentenced, Student/Teacher Sex, Tennesee
Monday, June 09, 2008
Code of Ethics
GOOD NEWS
June 9, 2008 - The Arkansas Board of Education unanimously approved a new code of ethics for Arkansas' 60,000 licensed teachers Monday. The code of ethics will go into effect Sept 1.
The teachers' union wanted to delay implementing the code. KFSM ch 5 called the code "controversial."
And yet, teachers still worry. "Are we supposed to be Big Brother here? Are we supposed to become sort of an educational Taliban?"TT - entry
Pickering, OHIO
"A serious error in judgement.."
June 9, 2008 - Pickerington Central High School Principal Scott Reeves apologized at the school board meeting for writing a letter in support of a man he describes as a friend who is charged with shooting two Columbus police officers.
The letter, written on district letterhead, said, in part,
“Derrick Foster is an honest, upstanding citizen who has been an inspiration to those around him,” Reeves said in the letter. “In no way is Derrick a threat or menace to the community, nor has he been anything but a respectful, law-abiding citizen.”Derrick Foster faces four counts of felonious assault of a police office after police say he fired shots that wounded two officers during a drug and gambling raid April 30 on the Near East Side. Foster has admitted firing the shots.
Superintendent Karen Mantia had written a letter to Reeves reprimanding him for using district materials and employee time to write a letter based on his opinions.
"The use of district materials and time used to write a personal letter in this fashion is a serious error in judgment," Mantia told him in a letter of reprimand.
"Furthermore, by sending this letter on district letterhead, you have sent a message to some members of the community that the school district may implicitly endorse your personal opinions on the matter."
Winston-Salem, NORTH CAROLINA
"People do do things wrong," he said.
ARRESTED May 16, 2007 - Police arrested Hubert Crosby, 46, a substitute teacher at at Reynolds and Mount Tabor high schools, and charged him with having illegal sexual contact with two male students.
The newspaper doesn't provide it, but if you have information, contact Police at (336) 773-7700.
Update May 17 - Fox8: The investigation began when another student at Reynolds High School told a teacher he has been offered money for sex. Next court date is June 8.
NEW TWIST May 20 - In a new twist, police learned that they were not notified that Crosby had been removed from the substitute roster in response to allegations of sexual misconduct until almost three weeks later when a second boy's family contacted police.
Delayed reporting. The district removed Crosby Apr 3, but Winston-Salem Police were not aware of the allegation until April 23. A Forsyth County Sheriff's Deputy school resource officer at the school investigating Crosby stopped his work after learning that the allegation didn’t take place at the school.
The deputy then suggested that the family contact Winston-Salem police, which police said didn’t happen. The County Sheriff's office didn't notify Winston-Salem Police either.
NEW CHARGES July 21 - Police filed two new charges of taking indecent liberties with a third student - a 15-year-old boy. Cosby is being held on $1.5 million bond.
GUILTY PLEA May 20, 2008 - Crosby pleaded guilty to three counts of sex offense with a student, five counts of indecent liberties with a child and eight counts of indecent liberties with a student. He was sentenced to seven to nine years in prison.
He will be on five years of probation after release, and, after that, 10 years of wearing a monitoring bracelet that allows him to be tracked by satellite.
Posted at
2:40 PM
Labels: Delayed Reporting, Male-Male, North Carolina, Sentenced, Substitute
Clarksville, MARYLAND
Sentenced to four years in prison and two trials to go.
Jan 12, 2007 - Alan Beier, 52, a teacher at River Hill High School, was arrested and charged with sex offenses and sexual child abuse involving two
students.
He invited a of a 16-year-old male to help him set up camera equipment at the school after hours, then talked student into disrobing for photographs. The student contacted police. Police found the photographs that matched the photos the student had described in a search of Beier's home.
During the investigation, police said, detectives learned that a 17-year-old female student had reported that Beier twice had sexual contact with her.
Full name: Alan Meade Beier
The Baltimore Sun reports that Brier is the second Howard County teacher arrested just this week. Joseph Ellis was arrested on numerous sex offenses. [Our entry for Ellis.]
Jan 13 - Beier, who was chosen River Hill's 2001 Teacher of the Year by the senior class, has been placed on administrative leave by the school system.
INDICTED Feb 9 - Brier was indicted by the grand jury on sexual misconduct charges involving a third student. Both Brier and Ellis remain on paid leave.
TRIAL DATE SCHEDULED Mar 5 - A trial date has been set for of Jul 23. He is still on paid administrative leave.
FIRING RECOMMENDED May 3 - The school superintendent has recommended firing Beier as well as Kirsten Kinley. TT link. They fired Joseph Samuel Ellis. His trial is scheduled for July 23.
PHOTOGRAPHS ADMISSABLE May 31 - A judge ruled that photographs of the boy that confirm his story would be admissable as evidence in the trial. The judge also ruled against a motion to dismiss charges. The jury trial is still expected to begin July 23.
TRIAL SUSPENDED July 12 - On June 25, a judge suspended Brier's trial while Brier's attorney files an appeal in the Court of Special Appeals to supress evidence police seized from his house at the time of his arrest.
MOTIONS HEARING August 26 - Beier will have a motions hearing November 9. Beier has appealed a recommendation by county Superintendent Sydney L. Cousin that the school board terminate his employment.
TRIAL SCHEDULED Jan 16 - Found in a story about Kirsten Kinley's lawyer's attempt to get her released. Beier is scheduled to go to trial on March 26 .
PORNOGRAPHY INADMISSIBLE March 21 - Circuit Court Judge Diane O. Leasure ruled that showing the "legal" pornography to a jury would be too prejudicial and could not be included as evidence at Beier's trial, which is scheduled to begin Wednesday.
The prosecution had argued that pornographic photographs found in Beier's home included adults in poses similar to those in the photos of the 16-year-old boy that were found on Beier's school computer, showing that Beier's intent in taking the photos was for nothing more than his own benefit.
GUILTY VERDICT March 28 - A Howard County judge Friday found Alan Beier guilty of second-degree assault and sexual abuse of a minor. Brier will be sentenced June 9.
Beier, who also is charged with fondling a 17-year-old female student on two occasions and with sexual misconduct with another male student. Both trials are scheduled for August.
NEW TRIAL DENIED June 6 - Circuit Judge Diane Leasure denied the request for a new trial based on the claim that his actions did not make up sexual exploitation. She is considering whether to permit Beier's request for a court hearing to challenge the affidavit police used to get a search warrant. She will rule on Monday when Brier is due to be sentenced.
SENTENCED June 9 - Brier was sentenced to to four years ** in prison. Beier could have faced 35 years in prison for the two convictions. TWO OTHER TRIALS are scheduled for August.
** June 10 story clarifed the sentence. Brier was sentenced to 10 years in prison with all but four suspended on the sex abuse conviction and five years with all but two suspended, to be served concurrently with the first sentence, on the assault conviction. She also sentenced Beier to five years of probation after his release and ordered that he must register as a child sex offender.
NO RELEASE September 4 - Brier will remain in prison while he appeals his conviction. He claimed news coverage caused some inmates at the Baltimore City Correctional Center to beat him last month. He was treated at a local hospital for a broken nose and facial cuts.
Judge Diane Leisure refused to release Beier on bail or home detention while he appeals his conviction. The violence described was "deplorable," she said, but the correctional facility, not the judge, should be responsible for the welfare of the inmates.
"Jail is probably not a place anybody wants to spend a lot of time," the judge said.
Seattle, WASHINGTON
Mandatory reporters who don't report child sex abuse.
June 8, 2008 - Seattle Public Schools this school year began requiring employees who work with children or supervise those who do to attend training on recognizing and reporting abuse.
Employees are still encouraged to report abuse to school or district administrators, but the policy now emphasizes that they have an independent obligation to notify police or Child Protective Services.
Adoption of the new training isn't due to the Broadview-Thomson case nor the Rainier Beach case, the school district says. And two principals involved in the Broadview-Thomson case won't face any formal discipline, but in the future, the district will investigate any employees who fail to report.
Prosecutors don't promise any such thing.
Ian Goodhew is the deputy chief of staff for the King County Prosecutor's Office.
Though prosecutors could make a case against school officials for not following the letter of the law, it's usually not in their best interests to do so, Goodhew said.-------------------------
Their best witnesses will be the person to whom the report was made, and calling that witness's professionalism or judgment into question by prosecuting him or her for failing to report in a timely manner could compromise the case against the abuser.
TT - That doesn't explain at all why those who fail to report aren't prosecuted after the abuser is convicted. We worry that there is an inherent conflict of interest in prosecuting educators who don't report because successful prosecution leaves the district liable to lawsuits for the wrongdoing.
-------------------------
Those who do report suffer.
The mother of one of Hill's victims, for example, caught him touching her daughter inappropriately and reported it -- then faced harassment from many in the school community.TT - So do teachers who report.
We suspect that is one of the major reasons teachers or administrators don't report sexual abuse of students by educators or by others, including abuse by other students. The other factor? Unions who supply accused teachers with free attorneys. In a union "them vs. us" mentality, you choose your sides.
Guess who loses?
Posted at
9:33 AM
Labels: Mandatory Reporting, Washington
