Monday, June 09, 2008

Background Checks

Police say background checks take 24-hours or are instantaneous.

June 9, 2008 - Police can conduct background checks in 24 hours. When the background check goes through the Arkansas Department of Education, it could take months. Two months after school bus driver Robin Clark was arrested, her background check was still pending. She had two drunk driving convictions in 1997 and 2001. A school bus driver.

The reason? School districts collect the information, send it to the state police, wait for the results. Send the information to the FBI and wait for the results. After a few more checks, if anything is discovered, the Department of Education has its legal office get more information. After getting information from the state police, the department has to contact the courts, get the documents relating to the case and evaluate the applicant’s record.

To combat the problem school districts are starting to hire private firms to conduct the checks.
--------------------
TT - What they don't tell you is that hiring a private background check company also circumvents the propensity of the Department of Education to issue waivers for teachers with criminal convictions, something that just about every state does.

The Arkansas Board of Education meeting minutes are online. You can find any number of discussions on waivers for individuals who have been convicted. Sample Something we noticed before.

Mind you, they aren't likely to be as ridiculous as one Oregon legislator wanted to go to pass a bill to allow schools to hire teachers who have been convicted of misdemeanor prostitution in the past.

It could be any U.S. state

Thank God, it's Canada. #689

June 9 - Quebec's largest school board has been ordered by the courts to rehire a teacher who is a convicted murderer.

Jean-Alix Miguel, an amateur kickboxer, pleaded guilty to manslaughter in 1990 after beating his common-law spouse to death. He served seven years in prison. A year later, he was hired as a teacher by the Commission scolaire de Montréal. When the school board found out about his past in 2004, they fired him. The teachers' union filed a grievance on his behalf.

You won't believe the rationale of the arbitrator and the courts. Teacher unions are the same everywhere.

Detroit, MICHIGAN

"the district celebrated some high points this year, including sending the only high school band from Michigan to the Beijing Olympics."
It's the only cause of celebration.

June 7, 2008 - The Detroit Free Press interviewed Connie Calloway in a story that began with this dire news.

Detroit public Schools budget deficit has grown from $45 million to $65 million -- and could grow higher, Superintendent Connie Calloway said.

In a wide-ranging interview she outlined a plethora of problems, including an ongoing FBI investigation, a continuing inability to evaluate teachers and a majority of high schools not meeting standards, thus failing in their duties to students.
The graduation rate in the district is, her staff says, 38%.

Calloway is in her first year as Superintendent and she knows the problems she faces.
She also has to bring the district's budget and employee numbers in line. That's no easy task. The public schools have been a jobs factory for decades. The district's budget is about the same as it was eight years ago, even though the number of employees and students has dropped by a third.

In 2000, the $1.2-billion budget paid for 21,203 employees and 154,648 students. Last school year the district spent the same amount of money to pay 15,535 employees and serve 105,000 students.
-----------------------
TT - Detroit is in danger of the school population dropping to below 100,000 which will trigger massive loss of funding, a prospect that doesn't worry the unions, according to an editorial in the Detroit News.

The charts at the Detroit Free Press article illustrate the problems she faces. As for the graduation rate, the numbers are varied and debatable. At best, Detroit could be described as dysfunctional. Education Week called Detroit "The nation's fastest-shrinking major urban school system." The district has lost 60,000 students since the late 1990s. Test scores are abysmal.

And while the schools burn, the mayor and his chief of staff, "lied about their sexual relationship last summer at a police whistle-blower trial that cost the cash-strapped city more than $9 million."

Happily for the mayor's political future, only 32% of 11th grade students in Detroit schools are able to read at or above grade level. The illiterate future voters will never learn of the scandal and taxpayers will never notice the high cost of the failure.

They paid $10,576 per student. Only 14% of 11th grade students in Detroit public schools were functioning at or above grade level in math.

Sunday, June 08, 2008

Teacher Code of Conduct

Speaking about delays.

June 8, 2008 - The Arkansas Education Association wants the state Board of Education to delay voting on a new code of ethics for Arkansas educators.

The teachers union say they support the new code but wants the board to postpone implementing it so the Department of Education and school districts have time to inform teachers about it.
TT - Not found at the story, the union objections are contained in a June 5, 2008 letter to Ms. Diane Tatum, Chairwoman of the Arkansas State Board of Education:

The AEA believes that later effective dates are necessary for the proper implementation of the Rules. The AEA is convinced that the Rules will work best if the Arkansas General Assembly passes two laws before they become effective.

The Board needs the authority to issue subpoenas in licensure appeal hearings, and legislation is necessary to provide an exemption from the Arkansas Freedom of Information Act that prevents the public disclosure of investigative information and records upon which no final action has been taken. Both measures are essential to the effective and successful operation of the Rules.
Subpoenas are a red herring. What they are advocating is an exemption from the Arkansas Freedom of Information Act for actions "when no final action is taken " so that when the educator - as many do in such hearings - opts for a settlement agreement that couples voluntary surrender of the teacher's license with nondisclosure, no one else will learn of the wrongdoing.

Why should wrongdoing be hidden just because someone admits it?

From 4029tv : (April 7, 2008) Teachers Shred Proposed Code of Conduct
The 13 page document outlines the code of ethics, but teachers said they are afraid they could potentially lose their license for things like drinking a glass of wine or not paying their debts on time the way the code is written now.
AND.
Many said they are worried the code is too broad and will make it too easy to revoke a teacher's license for moral matters.
TT - The media rarely distinguishes between teachers in the classroom and the choreographed performance of union activists who may, or may not be, teachers.

There are standards in the Code of Conduct: [Emphasis ours]
1. An educator maintains a professional relationship with each student, both in and outside the classroom.

2. …maintains competency regarding skills, knowledge and dispositions concomitant to his/her organizational position,subject matter and /or pedagogical practice.
3. …honestly fulfills reporting and contractual obligations associated with professional practices.
4. …entrusted with public funds and property honors that trust with honest, responsible stewardship.
5. …maintains integrity with students, colleagues, parents,patrons and businesses regarding gifts, gratuities, favors and additional compensation.
6. …keeps in confidence student records, personnel records, standardized test material and other information covered by confidentiality agreements.
7. …factually and appropriately presents the dangers of alcohol, tobacco and unauthorized / illegal drug use during the course of professional practice and in accordance with current state
law.
8. …abides by local, state and federal laws.


Professional Licensure Standards Board members are appointed by the state Department of Education and are "peers" of the educator. Members

June 9 - The Arkansas Board of Education approved the new code on Monday.

Cambridge, MASSACHUSETTS

When a gay activist complains about sexual abuse by a priest, the media respond like cocaine addicts to a line of white powder on a tabletop mirror. It's another story when students have their own tales of abuse.

June 8, 2008 - Daniel Weinreb is the lone protestor outside of Buckingham, Brown & Nichols, the exclusive Cambridge, MA, school.

He wants school administrators to openly acknowledge and investigate the sexual abuse he and others endured more than a decade ago at the hands of former teacher Edward "Ted" Washburn. The school doesn't need to fear lawsuits. The statute of limitations has long since run out.

Weintraub was 13 when he says Washburn asked him to perform a sexual act as he watched. Washburn pleaded guilty to raping his own nephew in 1987. Weintraub testified about his own abuse at the hands of Washburn at the trial. The educator was given a suspended sentence, ordered to continue psychotherapy, do 1,000 hours of community service, and stay away from boys age 16 and under.

It was a huge scandal. Washburn's father was the late Bradford Washburn, well-known explorer and director emeritus of the Boston Museum of Science.

Weintraub wants the school to improve efforts to find out if other students were victimized by Washburn, communicate with alumni about those efforts, and offer possible victims a weekend retreat with counseling.
-----------------
TT - Not mentioned in the article was Weintraub's website Opening BB Minds where he is trying to get in touch with other alumni and other victims. He posts their testimonials as well as letters from former faculty members.

At TT, we have a category called "Delayed Justice" for those students who have the maturity, determination and the courage to confront their abusers. Even if the abusers spend 50 hours behind bars after their conviction, it is a victory for the victim to have the truth established.

Because if we fail to do establish truth, we can find no solutions and justice becomes a whim.

Teachers have been having sex with students for a long time without recognition of the scale of the problem. In 2001, it was not difficult to find a news story a day about sexual abuse by an educator. That was when far fewer newspapers were online. Even today, we estimate that we only get 10-15% of the stories.

We know that because we visit teacher licensing boards and Boards of Education and local school boards where disciplinary actions include revocation or surrender of a license by a teacher and the surrender is not due to conviction, but is still listed as sexual misconduct with a student. That's because the age of consent is 16 in most states and teacher-student sex has been criminalized in slightly more than half the states.

Most states do not list their disciplinary actions against teacher licenses online, although states like New York list actions against 38 other professions. Educrats don't want the public to know.

Or other states.

When a Florida newspaper filed a public records request for a copy of the NASDTEC database, they summarized the Clearinghouse database of those teachers whose disciplinary actions were reported to the National Association of State Directors of Teacher Education and Certification. The database has been cited for decades as the means of assuring that teachers who lost their licenses in one state would not work in other states. New York had about the same number as South Carolina - 897 and 896. In 27 years.

Until every state posts disciplinary actions against teachers' licenses, as does Florida and a few others, parents can't know and won't know about the problem because it isn't a hot button media issue. You can readily see the difference in the number of stories out of Florida. This isn't because they have the most sexually active teachers. It's because of the Saratoga Herald-Tribune series raised awareness to the level where administrators are fearful of not reporting.

The quietly-negotiated surrender keeps the teacher out of the classroom, but it does nothing to help illuminate the problem so we can find a solution, so that we can get on with fighting a battle to make educrats accountable for the billions they spend every year.

And it delays the hopes of every parent for a decent education for the child, one that they thought they were paying for.

Saturday, June 07, 2008

Malvern OHIO

June 4, 2008 - Mark A. Commons, 22, a Malvern High School wrestling coach and tutor, was arrested on two counts of gross sexual imposition, both third-degree felonies. He is accused of sex with a 16-year-old girl. [He pleaded not guilty in court to sexual battery charges.]

It was Common's first year at the school where he was a tutor paid with federal funds. The girl's mother contacted Job and Family Services after Common showed up at their home last weekend, became angry and broke a door frame.
Full Name: Mark A. Commons

ARRESTED (Again) September 25 - Common was arrested Thursday on charges of intimidating a witness. The new arrest came after an investigation whether Common threatened witnesses involved in the case.

Common was charged with two third-degree felony counts of intimidation of a witness. He was taken into custody without incident at the Carroll County Sheriff's Office and was awaiting a bond hearing Thursday afternoon.

West Point, KENTUCKY

Sex with a 13-year-old student in 1977-1978 nets four years.

June 7, 2008 -James Skaggs, 60, West Point Independent School, 62, a teacher at West Point Independent School, was sentenced to four years in prison. A jury found him guilty in April of four counts of third degree sodomy for having a relationship with a 13-year-old student.

The relationship started in the fall of 1977 and continued through 1978, according to court records. Skaggs later became superintendent of the Cloverport schools in Breckinridge County.
Full Name: James B. Skaggs

April 21, 2008 - Veteran Educator Convicted On Sodomy Charges.
Jurors saw a taped confession from Skaggs during his trial and ultimately convicted him on four counts of sodomy.

Chicago, ILLINOIS

Sentenced to life for sexually abusing five boys.
Under Illinois law, any person convicted of more than one count of predatory criminal sexual assault faces a mandatory life sentence.

June 4, 2008 - Alonso Bracey, 38, a Barton Elementary School basketball coach and custodian convicted earlier this year of sexually abusing five boys, was sentenced Tuesday to life in prison.

The judge expressed a tinge of regret at having to inflict the heavy sentence on Alonso Bracey, 38, saying that in his nearly 20 years as a judge he had never sentenced someone to life in prison for a sex crime.

A jury convicted Bracey in February of sexually assaulting three boys and sexually abusing two others. Under Illinois law, any person convicted of more than one count of predatory criminal sexual assault faces a mandatory life sentence.
At the time, all the children were between the ages of 11 and 13 and were members of the basketball team he coached.

Hermiston, OREGON

June 5, 2008 - Roxanna Mata, 23, an educational assistant at Armand Larive Middle School, was arrested under suspicion of rape and sex abuse.

There are no details on the age of the victim, but rape in the third degree in Oregon means the person has sex with a victim less than 16 years of age. Sexual abuse II is when a person subjects a victim to sexual intercourse or deviate sexual intercourse. It also pertains if the victim doesn't give consent.

District Attorney Dean Gushwa said there were two victims in this case and there could be more. He said he anticipated presenting the case to a grand jury in the next day or two and his office may file additional charges.
Full Name: Roxanna Guadalupe Mata
Umatilla County

Coral Gables, FLORIDA

How can you explain the surge in middle-aged, female teachers having sex with teenagers? Oversexed comes to mind. We're going back to calling it Mommy Sex - when she's old enough to be your mother.

June 7, 2008 -
Christine Jouini, 38, an 11th and 12th grade teacher at the Center Academy, was arrested after police learned she had been involved in a sexual relationship with one of her male students for more than a year. The relationship began when he was 16.

Jouini was charged with three counts of unlawful sexual activity with a minor.

The victim recently confided to a teacher that he had previously had a sexual relationship with a teacher. That teacher notified the state child abuse hotline.

The boy stayed overnight when her husband was not home.
Photo BSO
-----------------------
A posted comment at the story:

As if the good teachers needed any more negative publicity. Isn't there some kind of psycho-test to see the tendency to do something like this? As a teacher of 8 years now, I have NO idea why a grown woman would have an interest in a high schooler or even more so, a middle schooler. Are these women just desperate for a need to feel attractive? I keep thinking maybe that's what it is, some unnaturally strong need to feel attractive, and it doesn't matter who it comes from. Sick.
-----------------------
June 7 - Enterprising KVAL13 news listed the schools where she has taught in the 2007-2008 school year. And the number of days she has substituted in 2006-2007 and 2007-2008.

Leitchfield, KENTUCKY

No charges filed, but district is firing the teacher.

June 5, 2008 - Complete story:

Trooper Steve Pavey said KSP (Kentucky State Police) was called several weeks ago by Grayson county School authorities concerning a complaint of sexual abuse or sodomy between a teacher, Adam Decker, and a 16-year-old girl at Grayson County High School.

After an investigation by Detective Matt Johnson no charges were filed. Pavey said relations between the teacher and student were consensual and therefore no laws were broken.

In Kentucky, the legal age of consent is 16 years. That law will change in July creating an exception for those in a position of authority such as teachers and scout leaders.
The teacher is "being fired" and is "now working in the private sector. "

Buffalo, NEW YORK

School officials failed to inform law enforcement officials or the boy's parents until more than three four months after a teacher witnessed the abuse and reported it.

May 28, 2008 - John Colazzi, 60, a teacher's aide at Discovery School, Public School # 67, was indicted on charges of sexual abuse in the first degree and endangering the welfare of a child for fondling a four year-old autistic boy in the bathroom in November 2007.

The boy is unable to testify about the incident, but a teacher who witnessed the abuse reported it to the principal shortly after the incident occurred. School officials failed to inform law enforcement officials or the boy's parents until more than three months later.

HUMAN RESOURCES DIRECTOR FIRED Joy Trotter, the human resources director who initially ruled the allegation "unfounded," was dismissed by Superintendent James A. Williams for mishandling the investigation.

CERTIFIED LETTER The teacher who witnessed the abuse sent a certified letter outlining her allegations to school superintendent James Williams. The superintendent admitted signing for the letter, but said he passed it on to a staff member without reading it.

The district attorneys office is preparing a report on where school officials "failed to respond properly" to the teacher's allegations. (Update: June 27, 2008 entry on Final report)

NOTABLE QUOTES
Buffalo Teachers Federation President Phil Rumore said, "[The teacher] was also told not to contact the parents, that she'd be insubordinate if she contacted the parents. She was told that by the principal, according to the teacher."
----------------
Buffalo School Board Member Ralph Hernandez, who asked the State ethics Committee to examine why this case was not turned over to District Attorney Frank Clark until March, says the scary part is this case could have been swept under the rug. "We don't know where the verdict will go, but if they must have some evidence. I think we did the right thing here, and hopefully it will be behind us."
----------------
UPDATE June 27, 2008 entry on Final report)

Friday, June 06, 2008

Tampa, FLORIDA

More than 20,000 words in excess of fame.

June 6, 2008 - Stephanie Ragusa wrote a letter to the son of Hulk Hogan who is incarcerated and the object of much media scrutiny. Nearly as much as she is.

Because of her track record and Nick Bollea is a minor, and the letter had a Falkenburg Road Jail return address, the letter was returned. Eventually a copy was given to Bollea.

We aren't even going to link to Ragusa's entry, nor quote from the letter. Ragusa, however, is famous for her weird smile in every mugshot and court scene. It's eerily like a string puppet doll smile with wooden eyes.

A poster at the story commented: "She still has a couple more months to tag him before he turns 18."

Long Beach, California

- Guilty plea, despite the best efforts of the local newspaper race-baiting rag and community activists semi-professional race-baiters who excuse any conduct, even violation of black youth.

- Sentenced to the minimum in prison and registration as a sex offender for life.

- The sendoff to the big house was touching.

Jan 31, 2008 - Dionn Holton, 32, a substitute for Long Beach Unified School District, was arrested on suspicion of unlawful sexual conduct with a minor. He is alleged to have sexually assaulted a 15-year-old boy.

Holton was arrested after the student told a Cabrillo High School staffer about two incidents that allegedly occurred on campus during school hours in late October and mid-December of last year. Holton was fired on Thursday.

He has been a substitute at half a dozen middle and high school campuses since August 2000. Holton was also an assistant basketball coach for the boys varsity team at Millikan High School.

Holton is the second basketball coach at Millikan H.S. to be arrested on suspicion of sex crimes since the start of the school year.

Head boys basketball coach Raul Olivas, also a mathematics teacher at the high school, was arrested on suspicion of secretly videotaping his 16-year-old stepdaughter in September after
the girl found a camera in her bedroom closet with graphic images of her in various states of undress. TT - entry

Long Beach police asked anyone with any information about Holton's possible contact with other children to contract Det. Hector Nieves at 562-570-7368

FAWNING Feb 2 - Holton a "former Poly High School basketball stand-out" and "West Coast Conference Freshman of the Year in 1995 at the University of Portland" working the same community where he grew up, etc, etc. etc. story in the Long Beach Press-Telegram.

Holton is scheduled to be arraigned at the Long Beach Superior Court on Monday.

HEARING DELAYED Feb 4 - Hearing delayed.

"I find it impossible that (Holton) could have done this."
[longtime friend Joe] Luyben said he worked very closely with Holton for three years and he said the 32-year-old husband and father of two
[TT - Holton has four.] children was an inspiration to the youths on the St. Anthony's team.

Citing other cases where teachers and coaches have been wrongly accused of misconduct by students who were failing academically or having disciplinary problems, Luyben said it appears as though the school district and city moved too soon to fire Holton from his jobs.


"He now has no way to support his family," Luyben said.

"His reputation is already ruined by the articles and all the other things that have happened."
TT - Great newspaper coverage and there's a good possibility that before any trial, the Long Beach Press-Telegram can run maybe five or six more stories to help bias a jury against the victim. With any luck, in the Southern California tradition, the newspaper could even get angry and disaffected youth to throw stones through the boy's window and threaten him and possibly burn his house down.
--------------------------------
Feb 8 - Awesome reporting.
Close to two dozen supporters filled the gallery of a Long Beach courtroom, and several more waited in the hall Friday, in support of a local substitute teacher charged with sexually assaulting a 15-year-old boy.
SHORT VERSION: His arraignment was postponed.

But they got this in:
A number of his supporters have said they believe the case is like others where students have falsely accused coaches and teachers of crimes to cover up their own disciplinary or academic problems, such as the case if Dominguez High Coach Russell Otis - who was acquitted of molestation charges in April of 2001. [TT and that's a distortion of what really happened.]
NOT GUILTY PLEA Feb 11 - Holton pleaded not guilty and he has a private lawyer who is catching up on the case. [Why the mention of a "private" lawyer is another matter that someone ought to examine. Closely.] The Private Lawyer wanted a photographer from the newspaper barred from the courtroom, a motion the judge denied.

The "Private Lawyer" argued that he wanted the case "to be tried in the court," rather than the media. The "Private Lawyer" also accused the Press-Telegram of what he called "inflammatory reporting" on the case for a line in a story that said police were asking anyone with information on the case to call Sex Crimes Detective Hector Nieves. [TT - The "private attorney" is one supplied, not by a union, but by the "community activists" and the "inflammatory reporting" remark is to keep community sympathy. Someone did this to Dionn!!!]

Bail was raised to $150,000. He'll be in court for a preliminary hearing on March 3.

GUILTY AS SIN March 20 - Holton pleaded guilty to both felony charges that he had a 15-year-old boy perform oral sex on him at school last semester. He must register as a sex offender for the rest of his life, the prosecutor added. He will be sentenced April 24.

TT - Criminals like this don't have "supporters." They have facilitators in the media, in the legal community and in the hatemongers who destroy community standards. Doesn't matter what the criminal does. He's black; they're proud. And if you don't think their little performances aren't meant to intimidate the victim and influence the D.A., you don't follow Southern California politics close enough.

SENTENCING DELAYED April 26 - Holton and his attorney requested a psychological profile in the hopes of finding a psychologist who will recommend probation so Holton can avoid prison. Sentencing was delayed until May 23.

SENTENCED May 23 - Holton was sentenced to 16 months in prison. He will have to register as a sex offender for life.

Sixteen months was the minimum term imposed by Judge Arthur Jean. Holton's lawyer provided the court with letters from former students, teachers, school administrators, relatives and friends that spoke highly of Holton's character and commitment to the community.

Yet, in a caption under the picture of Holton, the newspaper reported that the student student told authorities it was consensual, but he went to another staffer at his high school for help when Holton became too aggressive.

FAREWELL!!! FAREWELL!!! June 6 - Holton
surrendered quietly to authorities at the Long Beach Superior Court Friday morning.

A kiss and some words of encouragement from a relative were the last things the 32-year-old experienced as a free man before deputies snapped handcuffs around his wrists and took him away to begin serving a 16-month prison term.
Holton was accompanied by an aunt, who gave him a hug and a kiss and some encouraging words before he was taken into custody, court officials said.
-----------------
TT - Kinda like the Good Ship Lollypop with a cheery reporter from the Long Beach Press-Telegram waving farewell in print to a fond friend. Reality check. How many felons do you know who get coverage when they show up to go to prison?

He's a 32-year-old married man with four children who had a 15-year-old boy perform oral sex on him twice. In a school, for God's sake!

Lake Elsinore, CALIFORNIA

Franca sentenced to 240 days in jail - not prison - and registration as a sex offender for life.

Dec 16, 2006 - Franca Munoz-Juvera, 26, a Lakeside High School math teacher has been arrested on suspicion of lewd acts with a female student while the suspect's twin sister, Antonia Munoz-Juvera, 26, -- also a Lakeside teacher -- was arrested and accused of not reporting the alleged child abuse. Also arrested was Eileen Valerio.

The sisters, both in their first year in the school district, have been placed on administrative leave.
From left to right, they are Franca Munoz-Juvera, Antonia Munoz-Juvera, Eileen Valerio.

UPDATE: Jan 18, 2007 - Father's hunch lead to arrest. In September the father of the 16-year-old girl read an e-mail from from Franca Munoz-Juvera to his daughter and became suspicious. After talking to his daughter, he contacted the principal, vice principal and a sheriff's deputy. The vice principal later notified him that a background check showed nothing and no actions would be taken against the teacher, according to the father's account found in a request for a restraining order. He had to tape telephone conversations to get sufficient evidence for authorities to act.

COURT APPEARANCE Jan 23 - Court appearance scheduled for today, Friday by the latest. Valero is identified as the girlfriend of Antonia Munoz-Juvera by the victim. She posed as a student to drive the victim to meet with the teacher. Police are speculating that Valero might have been victimized when she attended Colony High.
"It makes sense," [Police detective Greco] said. "She was a student there. Her teacher taught there."

Update Mar 5 - On Monday, Lake Elsinore police detectives forwarded their reports to prosecutors, said detective Sgt. Evan Peterson. Prosecutors may soon decide whether to charge Franca and Antonia Munoz Juvera, 26-year-old twin sisters who live in the Rancho Cucamonga area in San Bernardino County.

ARRAIGNMENT SCHEDULED Oct 11 - After nearly a year, the three were charged in connection with a case of lewd acts with an underage girl who was a student at the school.. Court records state that arrest warrants have been issued for them and they are scheduled to be arraigned at the Hall of Justice in Riverside today.

CREDENTIAL SUSPENDED Oct 13 - Franca Munoz-Juvera's teaching credential was suspended because she was charged Tuesday with sexually abusing a minor, said Mary Armstrong, general counsel for the California Commission on Teacher Credentialing.

The school district has hired or designated an outside investigator to look into the Adelanto district's procedures that allowed the Munoz-Juvera sisters to be hired. He declined to comment further. (See entry on suspension.)

Oct 19 - From the Daily Press:

How could a woman dismissed from teaching in another district and under investigation for a sex crime involving a minor end up in Adelanto teaching children?
And then the reporter answers the question,

The Riverside Press Enterprise reported the policy of the Lake Elsinore school district was to answer all questions honestly and accurately when called as a reference, but that they do not volunteer information.
As for state records, it can take months before a credential is flagged.

GUILTY PLEA April 26, 2008 - Franca Munoz-Juvera pleaded guilty on Friday to committing a lewd act with a minor. She will be sentenced June 6. The judge told her that she could face from a year in jail to three years in prison when she is sentenced and that she will be required to register as a sex offender for the rest of her life.

Munoz-Juvera's twin sister and another woman pleaded guilty to misdemeanor charges of being accessories after the fact for helping the former math teacher spend the night with the girl. They will be sentenced June 6th.

SENTENCED June 6 - Franca Munoz-Juvera was sentenced to 240 days in jail - not prison - plus five years probation. She will also have register as a sex offender for the rest of her life.

Her twin sister, Antonia Munoz-Juvera , and Eileen Valerio, were both sentenced to four months in jail on a work release program and three years probation for being accessories after the fact.

Houston, TEXAS

June 6, 2008 - The Texas education commissioner ordered Sam Houston High School to close Thursday. The school has not met minimum academic standards for six straight years. According to the state, Sam Houston has the worst academic record of any school in Texas.

Roughly 2,500 predominantly poor, Hispanic students attend Sam Houston. Under state guidelines, if the school reopens, it must have a different name, a new principal and a new instructional program. At least 75 percent of the teaching staff has to be replaced, and half of the students who attended Sam Houston must be enrolled at other campuses.

A large part of the teaching staff replaced in 2005.

Only one other school has been forced to close since the state legislature gave the education commissioner the power to order school shutdowns in 2006. That was Johnston High School in Austin.

ABCtv: HISD closes Sam Houston HS
----------------------
WE FOUND: Sam Houston High School rates a 3 at GreatSchools.net for their poor academic performance. Where the state average for math on the TAKS test was 60% proficiency -- (Proficiency doesn't mean a math wiz. It means at, or above, grade level) - Sam Houston High School 9th graders scored 36%.

By 10th grade, State average 63%; Sam Houston 45% at, or above, grade level.
By 11th grade, State average 80%; Sam Houston 58% at, or above, grade level.

Teachers argue that poor students without parental support can't be expected to perform. But a school that has become a warehouse for the underperforming is not acceptable. The students manage other subjects despite poverty and without parental support. Language is not a barrier, even though the school population is 93% Hispanic. (See the English Language Art scores and social studies test scores, both of which require competency in English.)

Blaming blacks (4%) for lower math scores, as the Houston Chronicle appears to do, is to dismiss the potential of black students and willfully ignores the fact that no one at this school does well.

Math 9th grade - state average 60% at, or above, grade level
Whites score 45%
Blacks score 28%
Hispanics score 36%

Many large urban school districts have become poverty dumps where children are warehoused and remain in a cycle of failure for generations. What do schools care when they get paid by the student whether or not they perform? That's been the attitude for 40 years.

In a state where it took
three years in a battle with unions to change the reading standards, every movement toward change becomes a political battle. Closing this dump of a school is another step forward.

MAKEOVER APPROVED June 13 - The Houston school board unanimously approved a $3.4 million makeover Thursday of troubled Sam Houston High School -- a reform that's won cautious praise from several national experts who say success will depend on staffing, support and leadership.

Under state order, the plan will split the northside campus into two schools: one serving freshmen and the other for grades 10-12. The school for upperclassmen would emphasize math and science -- Sam Houston's weaknesses -- with a focus on preparing students for careers in engineering, information technology and the automotive industry.
The state will have to approve of the plan.

The state ordered the school must have a new name, though HISD officials contend "Sam Houston" can remain in the title. The district is temporarily calling the schools the Sam Houston Center for Math, Science and Technology and the Ninth-Grade Preparatory Academy.

A more significant name change could be beneficial, said Jack Jennings, president of the Center on Education Policy in Washington, D.C. "We have found that to be helpful because it gives an impression that you're going to start anew," he said.

Marion Center, PENNSYLVANIA

"We wanted to make sure he doesn't teach and that's the reason we entered the deal with him."

June 6, 2008 - William Menk, 35, a music teacher at McCreery Middle School, was sentenced to three years of restrictive-intermediate punishment (probation) including four months of electronic-monitored house arrest at a sentencing hearing April 4.

Menk pleaded guilty to a corruption of minors charge on Dec. 10. In a plea bargain with Indiana County prosecutors, Menk agreed to surrender his teaching certificate. In exchange, the district attorney’s office withdrew one count of unlawful contact with a minor.

Dec 21, 2007 - Teacher reaches plea deal in child pornography case

Court records show state police opened an investigation Oct. 25, 2006, to look into allegations that Menk had sexual contact with a 14-year-old girl.

A woman in Seattle told police she had frequent online conversations with Menk and said he claimed to have developed relationships with several underage girls in Internet chat rooms and on MySpace.com.
Troopers found a modified X-box in his home contained nude images of girls under age 18. The prosecutor amended the charges in January to add a felony count of sexual abuse of children. In March, police withdrew the original counts and Menk waived his right to a hearing for unlawful contact with a minor.
---------------
TT - We call it "Bargains" when a teacher "agrees to give up" their license in plea negotiations because it demonstrates how difficult it is to revoke a license when the license itself becomes a bargaining tool that gives the educator an advantage that no other citizen is given. Revocation should be automatic and guaranteed for sex offenders. That it is not is shameful.

Tarpon Springs, FLORIDA

June 6, 2008 - Christopher Jefferson, 37, a Tarpon Springs High School geography teacher, was arrested Thursday on a charge he stalked a co-worker for more than a year, police said. He was arrested when he went to her house uninvited to harass her, police said

The woman is a teacher at the school and the two were once romantically involved, according to the Tampa Tribune. The woman told police Jefferson had harassed her since early 2007 through phone calls and unsolicited visits to her home.

The district's Office of Professional Standards is also investigating the matter, will review the finalized police report, and "continue to monitor the situation over the summer and make an appropriate recommendation (regarding his employment status) at a later time."
-------------------------
Full Name: Christopher J. Jefferson
Charges: one count each of misdemeanor stalking and misdemeanor trespassing.
County: Pinellas
Florida Department of Education Discipline against Educator Licenses site.

Thursday, June 05, 2008

Dover, DELAWARE

CHARGES DISMISSED - His firing reaffirmed.

May 18, 2007 - Christopher Lehto, 34, an art teacher at Star Hill Elementary School, was arrested and charged with 4th degree rape -- by a person in a position of trust, authority or supervision -- after having sex with a former student.

The charge involves an alleged incident in April involving a 17-year-old high school student in the parking lot of a Wal-Mart shopping center. Detectives learned of the alleged relationship when a friend of the alleged victim told her mother and the mother contacted state police.

Authorities say the girl confirmed that she and Lehto had engaged in a sexual act. Lehto was released after posting a $5,000 secured bond.

Alleged Full Name: Christopher J. Lehto

UPDATE June 5, 2008 - The criminal action was dismissed because the elements did not exist. However, the school board fired Lehto on August 27, 2007. In a March 4, 2008 decision, Superior court Judge Robert B. Young affirmed the termination. C.A. NO: 07A-08-007(RBY)

Teachers are more than employees who regurgitate information to students. As previously stressed, in Delaware, teachers are regarded as role models.21 The Board here determined that Appellant could no longer serve as an effective role model to the students in his school due to his conduct. The Board determined that the relationship sent the wrong message to the District’s students about the appropriate relationships between students and teachers.22 That finding is the result of the enforcement of the Board’s determination of the community mores, which is the Board’s responsibility.

Friendship, TEXAS

Principal has accepted another administrative position effective immediately.

June 5, 2008 - The Friendswood Junior High principal who outraged some parents by allowing an Islamic group to make a 40-minute presentation to students last month is now off the job.

The school district said Robin Lowe "has accepted another administrative position effective immediately. "

Parents were incensed when about 875 seventh- and eighth-grade students attended the presentation given by two women with the CAIR (Council on American-Islamic Relations) in Houston. The pretext was that a Muslim student was "physically harassed."

David Bradley, a member of the State Board of Education whose district includes Friendswood, said parents have been contacting him to express outrage about the presentation. He said an assembly about Islam was a waste of tax dollars and was not an appropriate response to an attack on a student.

"There's a personal incident between two students and as a result of that we're going to yank everyone out of class?" he said. "I got beat up in junior high. Did my dad go down and force all the kids to sit through sensitivity training in their P.E. class? No, that's absurd. The coach gave us licks and sent us home. That was the end of those incidents."
TT - Ridiculously, the school superintendent said CAIR considered it a "hate crime."

You can find the PowerPoint slideshow here. The funniest one? "ISLAM Respecting Diversity."

Waunakee, WISCONSIN

Despite state law requiring school officials to report any reasonable suspicions of immoral conduct by a licensed educator to the Department of Public Instruction, Hirsch's resignation agreement stipulated no report to the state be made. And they gave him a "neutral reference." That was 2006.

Jan 3, 2008 - Anthony J. Hirsch, 32, a teacher's assistant for special education students at Waunakee Middle School, was arrested on suspicion of downloading child pornography from a group of Web sites being monitored by federal investigators.

The Federal Bureau of Immigration and Customs Enforcement contacted Madison police last month to let them know that Hirsch was a subject of interest in an investigation.

Hirsch formerly worked in a similar job at La Follette High School in Madison.

WKOW: "This isn't the first assistant teacher in trouble with the law this school year. Former Waunakee teachers aid [sic] Jacklyn Kaltenberg is charged with misdemeanors in connection with an underaged drinking party in October."

[TT - A police officer was fired for releasing police reports of the investigation to Waunakee School District Administrator Chuck Pursell while the investigation was still ongoing, then called the deputy director of the Wisconsin Intercollegiate Athletic Association. The reason given? Because the officer's son was on a rival football team. The reason seems odd to us.]

Correction: Town misspelled. Thank you, poster.

Feb 29 - WKOW investigative report (Feb 29) that uncovered the 2006 agreement received after they filed an state open records request.

Read the whole thing. It's great reporting.

In the January criminal complaint filed against Hirsch, authorities stated Hirsch admitted to being “ ‘addicted’ to pornography.” Hirsch is also charged with the repeated sexual assault of another LaFollette student in 2003 during her freshman and sophomore years, when she was 14. Authorities said Hirsch’s past actions with the girl were uncovered during the child pornography investigation.

From the Wisconsin State Journal : Hirsch was not reported in 2006.

Hirsch was allowed to quietly resign from the Madison School District in 2006 after a female student accused him of inappropriately touching her leg, according to interviews and public records.

And a May 2006 agreement forbade Madison officials from notifying the state Department of Public Instruction of the girl 's accusations against Anthony Hirsch, who was a special education assistant at La Follette High School.
Madison Superintendent Art Rainwater said Thursday that Hirsch 's conduct in 2006 didn 't meet that threshold to trigger notifying DPI.
"The district agreed to the conditions set forth in the memorandum in return for Mr. Hirsch 's resignation because while the district had concerns arising out of Mr. Hirsch 's conduct, the conduct did not rise to the level of terminable offense, " Rainwater said in a statement.

"The district agreed that it would not file a report with the Department of Public Instruction regarding Mr. Hirsch because the conduct at issue was not of the nature that required a report be made. "
More importantly, the school had to agree to provide a "neutral reference for Hirsch.
The agreement required the district to provide potential employers with a "neutral reference " of Hirsch limited to title, dates of employment and salary. It was signed by Hirsch, Madison Teachers Inc. Executive Director John Matthews and district Director of Labor Relations Duane McCrary.
---------------------------
TRIAL - Jury selection to begin June 16, 2008 8:30 am

NO CONTEST PLEA June 5 - Hirsch pleaded no contest to the repeated sexual assault of a child. In exchange for his plea. prosecutors agreed to drop child pornography charges.
Despite state law requiring school officials to report any reasonable suspicions of immoral conduct by a licensed educator to the Department of Public Instruction, Hirsch's resignation agreement stipulated no report to the state be made. Madison schools superintendent Art Rainwater has said Hirsch's alleged actions did not rise to a level to trigger the mandatory reporting.
During the investigation of the child pornography charges, police learned of his prior actions.
When detectives asked the young woman if she had been involved intimately with Hirsch, she hung her head and cried. The woman said that she was 14 and in the second semester of her freshman year at La Follette when she began an affair with Hirsch, meeting him often at his condominium near the school, where they would engage in sex.
---------------
TT - Surely it is up to the district attorney to decide if the actions rose "to the level of mandatory reporting," not a school superintendent. How can you trust the word of a school district that made that kind of awful agreement?

That's the problem with school districts who conduct Our Own Investigation. They have neither the incentive nor the trained personnel to conduct a thorough investigation. They have no knowledge of the rules of evidence, and no knowledge of the laws that might have been broken and no authority to compel cooperation. And amazingly, most often, they never find the evidence or witnesses that police manage to find.

When the hell will that stop?

Endicott, NEW YORK

It's federal sentencing. No parole.

June 5, 2008 - Michael Monnat, 61, a school bus driver and elementary lunch room monitor for the Union-Endicott school district, was sentenced to six years in prison for possession of child pornography.

Police started looking at Monnat after he asked a 10-year-old student at Charles Johnson Elementary School for her e-mail account and took a picture of her with his cellular telephone. The girl told her mother, and her mother told Endicott police.

Investigators set up a sting, and Monnat e-mailed the girl. Police got a search warrant for Monnat's home computer and found the images.
Monnat worked for the Union-Endicott School district for 20 years. He also worked with the Endicott Youth Baseball girls softball league. The Endicott Youth Baseball League relieved him of his duties as a board member when he was arrested.

He pleaded guilty in January after detectives found more than 600 images of child pornography downloaded onto his home computer.
-------------------
See our Link to Teachers and Child Pornography at the right.

Easton, PENNSYLVANIA

Before the Internet and video, t.v. coverage would never, ever show the participants or the lack of audience. A pre-planned protest with five people and an audience of 10 isn't exactly major.

June 5, 2008 - After LaToya Monroe, 29, was fired as human resources director by a 7-1 vote by the Easton School Board, "local black leaders" assembled by the NAACP challenged the hiring practices of the school board, saying minorities are consistently overlooked while board members manage to find positions for relatives.

Waltar Bright, a deacon with Easton's Greater Shiloh Church said, ''I would just like to have some questions answered about the previous hiring and firing practices of the Easton School District. It appears if you have the same last name of a board member, you get hired.''

Monroe who was paid $95,000 a year says the ''straw that broke the camel's back'' occurred when she recommended early this year not to hire the daughter of school board President Pat Vulcano.

Vulcano said Monroe is misleading the public.''When everything comes out, you may, in my opinion, be listening to a major liar,'' he said. ''She was not in the office enough to know what was going on.''

UPDATE August 20 - In a story about another school district hiring relatives, it was reported that the Easton board earlier this month hired Michele Vulcano as a full-time teacher, pending completion of necessary paperwork for her teaching certification. Her father abstained from the vote.
------------------------
TT - LaToya's picture here. The expensively-dressed deacon is on the video. There looks to be a whole 10 bemused people in the audience.

Montross, VIRGINIA

Plea agreement calls for to 41 years in prison - with all but 18 months suspended.
What kind of lowercase judge would accept that sentence?

June 5, 2008 -
Melvin Antonio Smith III, 21, a coach at Washington and Lee High School has pleaded guilty to four felony counts of soliciting sexually explicit material from members of a girls’ softball team last year. He also pleaded to attempting to have sex with a child 15 years or older.

In return for the guilty pleas, Westmoreland Commonwealth’s Attorney Dean J.Atkins agreed not to prosecute seven other felony charges and one other misdemeanor count against Smith. The plea agreement calls for to 41 years in prison with all but 18 months suspended. And Smith will have to register as a violent sex offender.

On July 14, Smith is scheduled to be tried in Richmond County Circuit Court on four felony charges of carnal knowledge of one of the players on the team, animate object penetration and taking indecent liberties.

Smith served for about a month last year as a volunteer softball coach at the school in Montross. Smith will be sentenced July 16.

Wellington, FLORIDA

Mark your calendars. They actually fired a teacher in Florida!!!

June 5, 2008 - Rutha G. Scott, 54, a business teacher at Palm Beach Central High, was fired by the Palm Beach County School Board for placing a student in a dark storage room for five to 15 minutes on Feb. 1. She had previously been suspended for 71 days without pay for doing the same thing at Olympic Heights High in 2006.

Administrators cited her for "unprofessional conduct, failure to exercise the best professional judgment" and other charges.

DECISION TO FIRE May 28 - Additional detail from a previous story. Now we know what professional judgement she failed to exercise.

Scott, an award-winning teacher and former adviser for Future Business Leaders of American clubs, had taught for 22 years. Though she received satisfactory evaluations over the past decade from principals, she has received two written reprimands and a suspension for misconduct including harassment and insubordination, and was the subject of several investigations.

In 1998 while at Spanish River High, a colleague accused Scott of harassing her in front of students and faculty. In January 2001, she was given a written reprimand for showing an R-rated movie against her principal's wishes and failing to supervise students during lunch. In December 2001, an investigation was launched into allegations that Scott unloaded about her then-principal Geoff McKee to her students.

A month later, Scott was given a second written reprimand for making malicious statements about Spanish River High's administration and teachers, wearing a leather tube top to school and failing to follow school procedures.

In December 2005 while teaching at Olympic Heights High, Scott was accused of putting a student in a locked storage room for 40 to 50 minutes after he refused to remain seated and quiet while she administered a test. Scott told investigators that she did not intentionally lock the door and said the student was in the room for only 10 minutes.

In 2006, the school board voted to fire Scott, but later rescinded the termination and suspended her after a subsequent investigation revealed the closet was larger - 8 feet by 9 feet rather than 5 feet by 6 feet - than previously thought.
----------
TT - Don't get your hopes up. They voted to fire her. She has appealed and will be given a hearing after which, if she loses, she can take the case to a labor board. If she loses there, an Administrative judge will hear the whole thing all over again. If she loses there, there is state court, followed by an appellate court, and finally the wholly-crackpot Florida Supreme Court.

In the meantime, folks, they will pay her salary and benefits. And if she pursues the case through the entire track, we'll know she's not paying for her attorney herself.

AND WE TAKE THIS BACK= But, gee, in the aftermath of the hugely reported teacher who conducted a Survivor-like vote to kick a five-year-old out of a classroom, this just sounds so -- responsible.

BEST NEWS OF THE DAY

June 5, 2008 - From the Associated Press:

Colorado Governor Bill Ritter has quietly signed a bill that requires teachers convicted of child abuse or illegal sexual behavior to agree never to teach again anywhere in this country.

The law requires the Department of Education to release the names of teachers and school employees convicted of such violations if it takes any action against their licenses.

It also requires school districts to notify the state if a teacher is dismissed or resigns because of allegations of illegal behavior with a child, including sex assault.

The law stipulates that if a teacher signs a settlement agreement with the Department of Education, the teacher must agree to never teach at a public or private school in this country.
The AP series documented a number of abuses.
According to records obtained by The Associated Press under the Colorado Open Records Act, the board over the past decade has signed settlement agreements with teachers convicted of serious crimes that allowed them to return to the classroom, even though the crimes included sexual assault on children.

The records show the board agreed to keep crucial details secret in some instances, including the case of a Northglenn teacher convicted of sexual assault on a child and allowing a minor to consume alcohol. The teacher received a two-year suspension, but the settlement agreement lists only the state statutes he violated, without saying what happened or where.

The board has said it was only following a law passed by the Legislature in 2003 requiring that teachers convicted of felony violent crimes be disciplined.

Teacher Misconduct - Canada

Letter from the Ontario (Canada) Catholic Teachers Association to their membership.

June 5, 2008 - A letter to the union's members was entered as evidence Thursday in the trial of F.J. Brennan teacher Mark Baggio.

Dear Colleague,

It has come to our attention that several teachers have been participating in interviews with police investigators recently. If you have not yet done so, you may be called and asked to participate in an interview in the future. For your information you are not obliged in any way to participate in an interview with investigators. If you wish to participate voluntarily, that would be your choice.

You should know that you have the right to end an interview at any time. Your may want to end an interview if you feel like you are not being treated properly and/or if you feel intimidated in any way or for any other reason. Also keep in mind that you as a teacher should not give "opinions" or offer professional "judgments" of your colleagues. You should stick to the facts as they pertain to the case at hand and not offer extraneous information or speculations.

Where interviews occur at work sites, we have a concern that an "interrogation" may be a form of harassment or intimidation. Our employer has a duty to maintain a work environment free from harassment. We have raised this issue with the Human Resources department and we are awaiting their response.
TT - Baggio, 34, is on trial charged with two counts of sexual assault, two counts of sexual exploitation and two counts of corrupting a child in relation to two girls he is alleged to have had sexual relationships with between 2000 and 2005, beginning when the girls were 14. The girls were students of Baggio's at F.J. Brennan Catholic high school. He was arrested in December 2005.

Los Angeles, CALIFORNIA

Middle school teacher arrested for possession of child pornography.
"We suspect that as a result of the Rooney case, there's heightened awareness on the Foshay campus." - L.A. Unified School District Superintendent David Brewer

June 5, 20087 - Lief Albaugh, 27, a band instructor at Foshay Learning Center, was arrested on one count of child possession. Investigators found pornographic images of young girls and boys on his personal laptop.

A former dean of students at Forsay has been accused of covering up in a case in which a former assistant principal had a sexual relationship with a student there.

[T]he Foshay dean, who was identified by authorities in court as "Mr. Hubbard," kept photos, notes and a scrapbook that documented the relationship between Rooney and a former Foshay student. Among the materials, presented by prosecutors in court last month, were photos showing Rooney and the underage girl kissing.
Despite that and without investigation, the assistant principal, Steven Thomas Rooney, was transferred to Markham Middle School, and he has been charged with molesting two students there.
Full Name: Lief Arnesen Albaugh

Los Angeles County District Attorney's Office Press Release (dated June 5, 2008)\
TT entry for Steven Thomas Rooney
TT entry for administrators charged with failing to investigate Rooney
TT entry for a principal and assistant principal for failing to report

TT - We think the heightened awareness is directly attributable to Superintendent David Brewer's decision to pursue such matters. He's a hero to us.

To be arraigned June 27.

ARRAIGNMENT June 27 - Albaugh pleaded not guilty yesterday (June 26) to a felony charge that he possessed child pornography on a school-owned laptop. He is scheduled to be arraigned July 9 on a second felony count of possession of child porn.
Officers allegedly discovered thousands of images of young boys and girls engaged in sexual conduct on both his LAUSD-issued computer and his home computer, according to the District Attorney's Office.
TT - L.A. District Attorney Press Release (dated June 26, 2008)

Los Angeles, CALIFORNIA

Teachers in one of the worst school districts in the country are planning to walk out in protest over state budget cuts.

June 5, 2008 - The Los Angeles Unified School District will be in court Friday to ask for a restraining order to try and stop a walkout by 40,000 teachers.

The action comes after the state Public Employee Relations Board earlier this week denied the district's request for an injunction against United Teachers of Los Angeles, the 48,000-member teachers' union.

Teachers are planning to spend the first hour of school on Friday on picket lines to protest a projected $353 million cut in state funding for the district for the upcoming school year. The union says teachers will not be paid for that hour.
----------------
TT - The state is running at a $17 Billion - with a B - deficit and legislators are yet to approve the 2008-2009 budget. That budget is also projected to be $10 - $15 Billion - with a B. Much of that is due to declining revenues due to the subprime mortgage problems and a decline of up to 15% in home values. California chronically depends upon deficit spending and long-term loans in the billions to finance their spending sprees, but tighter markets and a poor credit rating mean they can no longer borrow that kind of money on the bond market.

The Los Angeles Times reported in February that state revenues have been in such rapid decline that fiscal analysts warned California was in danger of not having enough cash on hand to pay its bills by this summer. Governor Schwarzenegger is candid about the reasons: If education, health and other state services were spent responsibly within their budgets, there would be no budget crisis.

The governor’s solution is to balance the budget by borrowing $15 Billion -with B - against future lottery proceeds and changing the lottery to make it more profitable - that is, if anyone is willing to fork over the money to spending junkies.
To get Wall Street to lend the state the $15 billion against a modernized lottery, Californians would have to pay $23 billion to $30 billion in interest and other borrowing costs over the next 30 years.
Click on the picture at this story to see protesting teachers. This is how Greatschools.net rates Compton schools, a city that is the gang and crime capitol of Southern California.


Teachers in schools that rate 3, with 1 being the lowest, don't deserve a raise. They aren't earning what they're paid now.