Thursday, June 05, 2008

Auburndale, FLORIDA

Polk County Sheriff Grady Judd said today, "It's painfully obvious to us that she's a pedophile."

June 5, 2008 - Danielle Jones, 32, a Stambaugh Middle School 6th-grade science teacher, was arrested and charged with sexually assaulting four male students between ages 14 and 16 years old. The victims were black; Jones is white as seen in the picture here and in this video. (We got the picture later.)


The sheriff says the five would communicate over Myspace.

Judd says Jones refered the victims as "her boys," in 50 pages of emails seized through a search warant.

Judd said, at a lunchtime news conference, Jones would have threesomes with some of the victims. One victim told detectives Jones had sex with two boys ten times in one night. There were a total of five different sexual meetings, according to deputies. In each case, Jones would allegedly pick the victims up and drive them to her house for the liasons.
FOX13: Detectives believe a fifth boy may also be involved, but he has not been named. The sexual relationships came to light when one of the first boys involved with Jones told another teacher about it on May 16 of this year.
See Video of the Police Chief's news conference from the FOX site.

Photo Polk County Sheriff's Office.
----------
ONLINE RESOURCE: Polk County teacher discipline records.
----------
LETTER OF REPRIMAND June 6 - Polk Teacher Charged With Sex With Teen Boys
There was a letter of reprimand in Jones' file.
It has come to my attention, and to the attention of Mr. Chuck Smith, investigator for the Polk County School Board, that you have allegedly established a pattern of allowing young male students, some of whom you do not currently teach, to enter your classroom before, during and after school hours for visitation, hugs, tickles and flirtatious non-school related conversations,"[Stambaugh Principal Allison] Kalbfleisch wrote in a Jan. 23 letter to Jones.

"I insist that you never have casual, non-school-related physical or verbal contact with any student on campus whom you do or do not currently teach."

"In addition, I insist that you are never alone in a classroom with any male students."
It was written five months after the alleged relationships that led to her arrest. Four months after the reprimand, Jones was arrested.

Jones' arrest comes after two Polk county teachers and a principal were arrested on sex-related charges.
-------------------
TT entry for Isaac Nathan Tillis
Bartow teacher. Before his arrest in Dec 2007, there were two allegations against him that were deemed unfounded. The investigator determined there wasn't enough evidence to support the accusations.

TT
entry for John Stelmack
Lakeland elementary school principal. Child pornography possession. Stelmack had previously been suspended with pay due to inappropriate behavior toward certain students, including excessive hugging. After his arrest, they learned he had resigned from his previous school due to parent complaints.

TT
entry for James Mark Mason
Lakeland Catholic school teacher. Sentenced to five years in prison and five years probation for child pornography possession. A student found a thumb drive with the child pornography in the school's computer lab. Prosecutors say Mason did not have a permanent address before he was hired and was moving from hotel room to hotel room.

Hull, MASSACHUSETTS

He was supposed to serve as a aquatics director this summer at a summer camp for children aged 5 to pre-teens. Seriously creepy.

June 5, 2008 - Russell Goyette, 61, the former principal (2002-2004) at Hull High School and a longtime teacher, was arrested on possession of child pornography charges after a grand jury indicted him Wednesday.

Police received a tip more than a year ago that Goyette had child pornography on his home computer. They applied for a search warrant in June 2007 and referred the case to the state Attorney General’s office in February. Prosecutors say a search of Goyette’s personal computer netted more than 4,500 images of children engaged in sex acts with adults and other children.

Assistant Attorney General Anne Yas said Goyette had viewed the images as early as 1999, while he was still head of Hull High School, and had categorized the smut by “sexual fetish.” She called the kiddie porn images “graphic and very disturbing.”
The anonymous tip was from a former girlfriend who found the images on his personal computer that he left behind when he moved out last year.

Compare the picture at this story with this picture.
---------------
See our Link to Teachers and Child Pornography at the right.

Operation Centurion

The arrests have been headlines in Australia for days.

  • 90 arrests
  • 4 teachers
    • June 5, 2008 - One of the largest child pornography sweeps in Australia resulted in 90 arrests. Four of those arrested were teachers. One committed suicide, another attempted suicide.

      A 59-year-old Sunshine Coast teacher committed suicide after being charged on two counts. Another, a Queensland primary school teacher, 48, caught in the police swoop, was taken to hospital late yesterday. It is believe he had also attempted suicide.

      More arrests are expected in coming weeks with at least 1500 Australians - using 2883 IP addresses - under investigation. More than one million illegal images were unearthed on computers, DVDs, CDs and other material during raids led by the AFP.

      The investigation began when hackers placed nearly 100 photographs on a legitimate site in Europe. Within three days the images had attracted 12 million hits -- from 144,000 IP addresses across 170 countries.

      Another six people who worked with children had their accreditation removed.
      ------------
      See our Link to Teachers and Child Pornography at the right.

      Elon, NORTH CAROLINA

      June 5, 2008 -
      Leslie Troup, 23, a teacher's aide at Western Alamance High School, was arrested and has been charged with charged with four counts of providing alcohol to people under the age of 21 and nine counts of sexual offense with a student by school personnel.

      She is accused of committing a sexual offense against an 18-year-old male student at the school. (He was under 18 when the initial offense occured.)

      An April 19 investigation resulted in underage drinking charges against nine students at the school which lead to the investigation of Troup. Troup left the Alamance-Burlington School System before the charges were filed against her. She was being held on a $1 million bond.
      Full Name: Leslie Marie Troup

      Alamance County

      Ocala, FLORIDA

      June 5, 2008 - Shannon Vianello, 38, a remedial elementary reading teacher, was found guilty of driving under the influence. She was sentenced to one year of probation, ordered her to perform 80 hours of community service, serve 30 days on the Sheriff's Office work gang and ordered that she must not possess or consume alcohol or drugs. Her driver's license was suspended for a year.

      She was arrested March 11 while driving from one assigned school to another. Three officers went to the school because several people called 911 saying someone was driving erratically, and the tires on the right side were flat. She told police she was a diabetic. A parametic checked her blood sugar and told the officer that her blood sugar was fine.

      At the jail, she blew a 0.277 and a 0.266. The legal limit is 0.08.

      FIRING RECOMMENDED June 6 - Marion County Public Schools has recommended that Vianello be fired.

      "At this point we are planning to terminate her now that the conviction has been handed down," he said Thursday afternoon. "The district came to that decision based on the fact that she drank on the clock."
      Following the arrest almost three months ago, Vianello was never suspended from her position.

      RESIGNED June 9 - Vianello resigned, citing personal reasons. The resignation came on Friday, the day after school officials announced they would recommend dismissal.

      Such a conviction does not mean she will automatically lose her teaching certificate. It depends on the circumstances, according to the state Department of Education. State officials also could put her on a probation plan, DOE said.

      Springdale, ARKANSAS

      Middle school teacher intoxicated in classroom.

      June 5, 2008 - Janice Dodson, 59, a teacher at J.O. Kelly Middle School, was arrested for public intoxication after other teachers complained of smelling alcohol on her breath.

      Dodson reportedly had been in her classroom with students present. She was visibly upset, according to the police report, while telling her students about a pending surgery.

      She later told police she had been drinking wine since the previous evening, and continued drinking wine until 5 a.m., according to the report. She registered a .192 on a field breath test, the report states. The legal limit in Arkansas is .08.She also told police she was taking prescription drugs, according to the report.
      She is the second teacher to be arrested last month inside a Springdale school. Patricia Miller was arrested for driving under the influence at Young Elementary School in early May after failing two field sobriety tests in her classroom. The charge stemmed from driving herself to the school.

      School Board Watch

      Think he's got the backing of the NEA?

      June 5, 2008 - Christopher Renner is a Democrat candidate for the Kansas Board of Education.

      Renner works as a property manager and talk show host but previously worked in education, including a stint from 1999-2002 as a program consultant with the Kansas State Department of Education.

      Lately, he has been taking courses in journalism at Kansas State University and hosting a public affairs show on the campus radio station.

      If elected, he said he would support comprehensive sexual education, improving teacher pay, encouraging young people to go into education, easing any bureaucratic red tape preventing people from being licensed to teach and promoting changes to the federal No Child Left Behind legislation.
      -------------
      TT - Radio station blurb. The show is "the progressive alternative to the radio talk shows on Manhattan airwaves."

      Aggravated child rape

      House passes aggravated child rape bill.

      June 5, 2008 - Even in ultra-liberal Massachusetts where there is no mandatory minimum for child rape, the House approved on a 145-3 vote a bill that would create the new crimes of aggravated child rape when a weapon is used, when the victim is drugged or when the perpetrator is in a position of authority such as a teacher, coach or clergy, and impose a mandatory 10-year sentence for first offenses.

      It took two years on the part of State Rep. Karyn E. Polito, R-Shrewsbury to get even that concession. During the budget she forced the issue to get a commitment that it would come out of committee so that tougher sentencing for crimes against children would be debated. Democrats rejected her arguments to impose a mandatory minimum 10-year sentence for rape of a child with force.

      Leroy, ALABAMA

      We told you firing a tenured teacher was hard to do. More people are finding out just how true that is.

      June 5, 2008 - A report from Jessica Taloney at WKRG.com Ch 5 on the attempt to fire Charlene Schmitz.

      A Washington County teacher is collecting a paycheck from jail.

      Charlene Schmitz, 55, was sentenced Monday to ten years and one month for using a computer to make sexual advances on one of her eighth grade students. Schmitz was convicted on two counts of the federal charge by a jury in February.

      Two weeks after her conviction, the Washington School District voted to fire Schmitz and terminate her $51,666 a year salary, but News Five has learned the Alabama Office of Administrative hearings overturned the school board's decision.

      "The board has done everything they could do to get her off the payroll," said Martin Pearson, the school district's attorney. "They're aware it's taking tax payer dollars, but at this point their hands are tied," he said.

      Pearson says Schmitz, who still faces state charges for rape and sodomy, appealed her termination. In an opinion issued on April 23rd by Walter Turner, Alabama's Chief Administrative Law Judge, the Office of the Attorney General sided with Schmitz, saying "there is no provision in the Alabama Teacher Tenure Act, or any other statue, for the suspension of a teacher's salary pending the termination or suspension process under any circumstances."

      Basically, Pearson says that means Schmitz must have an administrative hearing before she can be terminiated, and based on the concept of due process, Schmitz can't be forced to testify at an administrative hearing until after her criminal proceedings are over.

      "I don't think it's fair at all," said Kesler Weaver, who serves on the school board and voted to fire Schmitz. "We should be able to terminate her under the circumstances.Donna Marks, the victim's mother, agrees. "She is in prison, she is drawing a paycheck, paying an attorney to fight us, the victims," said Marks. "It makes absolutely no sense."

      Schmitz attorney says he expects to appeal the federal conviction and sentence. Schmitz's state trial is scheduled to begin in November.
      TT entry for Schmitz.

      Wednesday, June 04, 2008

      Port St. Lucie, FLORIDA

      Poor judgement and a deplorable lack of sensitivity.

      May 28, 2008 - A teacher in South Florida was reassigned after allegedly allowing her students to vote, "Survivor"-style, as to whether or not to let a 5-year-old autistic student back in after he was sent to the principal's office.

      By now, everyone knows the name of Wendy Portillo, 29. She was taken out of the classroom and reassigned. The school district is conducting an investigation and will have a report in two weeks.

      The Times-Record (Wichita Falls, TX) editorialized (June 1) that her lack of concern for child should be a cause for dismissal.

      Now he’s shadowed by the nightmare of having his classmates turn on him, at the encouragement of an educator.

      The election process wasn’t even by secret ballot.

      Portillo allowed each child to say, in front of Alex, just what they didn’t like about him. Words like “disgusting” and “annoying” were offered.
      The state attorney's office declined to prosecute for "emotional child abuse." The newspaper thinks "the district should send this so-called educator quickly into another career path."
      ----------------
      TT - If they dismiss the teacher, it will only be because of public pressure. There were, at last count, 152 stories on line. Teachers in Florida can't be fired for being convicted drug addicts or for having multiple DUI convictions, are acknowledged alcoholics, nor are they automatically fired for having sex with underage students even when the administration knows it is true. The teacher is given what amounts to a public benefit of doubt even when the student isn't afforded that kind of support. This is true in just about every state.

      Tenure, archaic labor laws, labor unions, administrative courts, and the protections afforded by negotiated contracts pretty much dictate that no teacher will be terminated outright even if they don't teach, physically or sexually abuse children, or if a 48-year-old teacher has sex with 17-year-old student.

      Some school districts do fire the educator anyway, but it is really a P.R. exercise to demonstrate that they are doing something. They know it is just a gesture because labor laws mean that the educator can appeal - endlessly. And at no cost to themselves. The union supplies lawyers who will challenge the issue to the state supreme court if necessary. (Especially if the educator is a union president.)

      The teacher in South Florida serves as a good example of what's wrong in government schools. She obviously has no flair for education and ought to voluntarily find another job. She probably won't and it's unlikely that a district will get rid of her, short of offering her a full pension and five to ten years' salary to go away. Whether they offer the money in a lump sum or not, that's roughly what they'll pay anyway for the lengthy process involved in terminating a teacher when the teacher and their union opposes the action.

      It will be interesting to see if the teacher gets gonged herself.

      It's kind of a selective outrage, however, to speak about the classmates who turned on the boy at the encouragement of an educator - and that's using the word loosely - without wondering how a victim feels when an teacher or colleague sits behind a fellow teacher in a courtroom in full view of a student who has been victimized? Or, worse, testifies for a colleague?

      The only time a 15-year-old cried in the courtroom was when she saw the teacher she was assigned to next year sitting in the court - behind the girl's victimizer. Even after conviction teachers, co-workers, and colleages write letters asking for leniency for the teacher. Colleagues and students in White Plains, NY, asked for leniency for a teacher convicted of possession of child pornography. A half dozen teachers and staff showed up for the sentencing. A supporter shouted, "We love you, Allen. Nothing has changed."

      As educators, wouldn't you expect that they would write letters demanding the maximum sentence because the victims were children?

      We aren't talking about the world's most sensitive human beings and that, sadly, is not unique to teaching. But, still, shouldn't we expect more? And the first ones who will tell you we should are the good teachers who see their profession demeaned by the actions of a few.

      Grand Coulee, WASHINGTON

      Letter to the editor of The Star.

      June 4, 2008: "Felon freed after sentencing"

      Is this justice?

      Vernon Heizer rapes a child, no prison sentence-should have received 34 months for rape, 20 for child molestaion. Judge Culp dismissed one count of third-degree rape and communication with a minor for immoral puposes.

      Heizer did get a $15,000 settlement from (the school) district, gets to move, gets outpatient treatment. Did they also buy him cake and coffee?

      This person was a teacher-police officer; for shame on him and that court. This is not acceptable, and not justice.
      TT entry entry for Hiezer. He was 50; his victim was 14.

      Marshall, MINNESOTA

      Another band teacher in the news.

      June 4, 2008 - Lori Schulz, 33, a Marshall Middle School and Junior High band teacher, was charged with criminal sexual conduct in the second degree and fourth degree.

      The complaint alleges that Schulz had sexual contact with the student, a 14-year-old girl, from January to May 2003, while Schulz was the junior high band teacher, the complaint alleges. The student was in band.
      Full Name: Lori Ann Schulz
      ----------
      TT - The reason why so many band teachers have inappropriate relationships with students may be the same reason why coaches do. The best explanation was in a 2001 series in the Houston Chronicle by Danny Robbins, "Out of Bounds."

      The number of coaches involved in sexual misconduct with students is generally attributed to two factors. One is the amount of unstructured time coaches and students spend together. The other is the power and stature of coaches, particularly those affiliated with successful programs.
      ---------
      June 5 - When Marshall Police interviewed Schulz she said she was no longer teaching but working in an administrative job in a factory, the complaint said.
      “First of all it’s disappointing something of this nature may have occurred,” Marshall Superintendent Klint Willert said. “It would be disappointing from anybody’s perspective.”

      Willert said the allegations are especially disappointing because of Schulz’s abilities and musical work at the school.“

      She was highly revered by many for her musical abilities and for what she did for the district. She had very high performing bands and musical groups,” Willert said of Schulz.
      OMNIBUS HEARING July 16 - Judge George Harrelson ruled Tuesday there was probable cause for the charges against former Marshall School band teacher Lori A. Schulz.
      Lyon County Assistant Attorney Tricia Zimmer filed a request for an aggravated sentence which would be an upward departure on a sentence if Schulz is convicted. Zimmer said in her request in the case where a victim is "vulnerable to age, infirmity, or reduced physical or mental capacity which was known or should have been known to the offender," an aggravated sentence is justified.

      Zimmer also said Schulz "engaged in 'grooming' behavior over a period of time and used pressure, duress and threats of suicide." Schulz also "committed multiple acts" over an extended period of time, Zimmer said in her request.
      Schulz's lawyer Joel Solie requested a plea hearing. Harrelson said a hearing would likely take place within three or four weeks.

      Wenatchee, WASHINGTON

      The judge acknowledged the letters and statements but made clear his bottom line:
      "The court does not sentence a person for who they are or what they believe but rather because of what they did. This is indeed unfortunate Mr. Mora finds himself here."

      March 19, 2008 - Nestor Mora, 30, a teacher's aide at Pioneer Middle School, pleaded not guilty at his arraignment. Mora is accused of raping a 14-year-old boy he met at the middle school and contacted through MySpace.

      Wenatchee police arrested Mora on March 6 on suspicion of kissing, fondling and performing oral sex on a 14-year-old boy in January. On March 12 he was charged last week with third-degree rape of a child, third-degree child molestation and possessing child pornography. Police suspect Mora, a classroom aide for four years, of getting to know the boy through the social-networking Web site MySpace. He is accused of performing oral sex on the boy.

      Mora worked at three elementary schools since 2003. ***
      Full Name: Nestor Eloy Mora

      March 19 - "Mora's interaction with students a concern before arrest"
      At least three teachers and one administrator at Pioneer Middle School expressed concerns about Nestor Mora's relationships with students in February. At that time the school principal wrote a "letter of direction" to Mora. The letter gave specific directions for Mora to change his behavior or else disciplinary action could be taken.

      Mora is on paid administrative leave.

      FIRING RECOMMENDED March 29 - A Wenatchee School District administrator is recommending the School Board fire Mora. The superintendent of human resources, Steven Cole, said the content in Mora's taped interview with police warrants his immediate firing. Mora was notified in a letter.

      ** The three schools are Lewis and Clark Elementary School from February to June 2004 and at Washington Elementary School from February 2004 until February 2006. And Pioneer Middle School from October 2003 to February 2004, and again from February 2006 until his arrest.

      BOND REDUCED April 8 - A judge reduced Mora's bail bond from $250,000 to $100,000. His trial is scheduled for May 6.

      POSSIBLE PLEA CHANGE April 16 - Mora was scheduled to appear in court this afternoon. The schedule for today's Superior Court appearances that came out this morning lists Mora with the subject line "Change of plea."

      Weeks before Mora's arrest, Pioneer Middle School Principal Mark Helm wrote in a letter to staff that three students had told them Mora communicated with them on MySpace. A "letter of direction" from Helm to Mora ordered him to not contact students through MySpace.

      GUILTY PLEA April 17 - Mora pleaded guilty to third-degree child molestation, third-degree rape of a child and luring. Prosecutors recommended a 20-month sentence. Sentencing is scheduled for June 4. The deputy prosecutor said he met with the parents of the victim and they support the deal.

      In part because federal authorities are investigating, the state dismissed a charge of possessing depictions of minors engaged in sexually explicit conduct. "This is not going away for Mr. Mora," [prosecutor Roy] Fore said. "The feds have advised me they're taking the case."

      SENTENCED June 4 - Mora was sentenced to 17 months in prison.

      TRIAL SCHEDULED August 21 - A trial on child pornography possession charges was scheduled for Monday. However, Mora's lawyer wanted more time to review the evidence. The trial has been rescheduled to begin Sept. 8.

      The lawyer also said discovery information provided by the government on July 22 "was particularly significant as an alleged victim was identified that could lead to additional charges."

      Riverton, UTAH

      Mandatory reporter charged for failure to report child sex abuse.

      June 4, 2008 - Shelley Nordick, 46, Rosamond Elementary School principal, was charged with failing to report child sexual abuse in connection with a teacher convicted of molesting students at her school.

      The abuse was perpetrated by teacher Frank Laine Hall, who last year admitted to molesting 11 of his first-grade students and was sentenced to 15 years to life in prison.

      Failure to report child abuse is a class B misdemeanor, punishable by up to six months in jail. Nordick, 46, is scheduled for arraignment in Riverton's Justice Court on June 17 before Judge Gregory Bown. Hall committed his crimes between July 2005 and March 2007, according to 3rd District Court documents.
      Deseret News (June 4): Principal in teacher abuse case charged
      The date of Nordick's non-reporting was listed in court documents as "March 13, 2008." Hall was arrested by police near his house on March 15, 2007.
      Nordick will be arraigned June 17.
      -------------------
      TT Entry for Frank Laine Hall.

      From Susan K. Smith's website on Mandatory Reporting:

      All states require certain professionals and institutions to report suspected child abuse, including health care providers and facilities of all types, mental health care providers of all types, teachers and other school personnel, social workers, day care providers and law enforcement personnel. Many states require film developers to report.
      There are links to reporting laws in every state.


      We recently came across a 2005 paper by Daniel C. Swinton, "Criminal Liability, Failure to Report Child Abuse, and School Personnel:An Examination of History, Policy and Caselaw" that concludes that "the criminal liability affixed to mandatory reporting statutes for school personnel is hardly more than window dressing, or a vague, unrealized threat."

      He also notes that teachers have consistently reported a lower percentage of cases than other professionals.
      ------------------
      MORE THAN ONE COMPLAINT June 5 - Nordick received complaints reports about Hall's behavior in August 2006 and again in March 2007. Hall was not removed from the classroom until seven months after the first complaint.

      NOT GUILTY PLEA June 15 - Nordick was scheduled to have an arraignment Tuesday in Riverton Justice Court. Instead, she and her attorney, Blake Ostler, have submitted a not guilty plea in writing to the court. A pre-trial hearing is scheduled for July 15.

      COURT APPEARANCE July 15 - Nordick appeared in court and pleaded not guilty.

      Also in attendance at the hearing were numerous teachers at Rosamond Elementary who believe Nordick is being unfairly targeted."We are all angry that the city is bringing these charges," said Jennifer Brown, a kindergarten teacher at Rosamond.

      "She is a remarkable principal," added Christine Mackerell, a 3rd grade teacher at Rosamond.

      Officials say that Nordick got wind of sex abuse allegations involving Mr. Hall at some point, and preliminarily investigated the reports by talking to various people and observing the teacher's behavior -- but she did not contact authorities.

      After Tuesday's hearing, Ms. Nordick left the courthouse through a side door -- where she appeared visibly upset and frightened.
      The Salt Lake Tribune (July 17) Riverton principal denies not reporting teacher's sexual abuse of students
      Subhead: Teachers, parents angry city is making case against her, call it 'witch hunt'

      TT - No attempt by these newspapers to educate the public, parents, or students about mandatory reporting laws.

      TRIAL SCHEDULED September 1 - Nordick's trial is scheduled for November 20. This, reported by The Salt Lake Tribune, the story beginning in this fashion:
      Rosamond Elementary School Principal Shelley A. Nordick - who some say is a pawn in a feud between the Salt Lake County Sheriff's Office and the Jordan School District over the district's child-abuse reporting policy - will take her case to a jury.
      TT - Who the "some say" who think it's a feud? Oh, wait, it's The Salt Lake Tribune. See What the hell is vague about ... (TT Link)

      Amsterdam, NEW YORK

      Munn sought psychological counseling even before her arrest, prosecutors said, explaining why they agreed to a light sentence. (We love the pity picture.)

      Sept 13, 2007 - Elizabeth Munn, 32, an eighth grade social studies teacher at Broadalbin-Perth Middle School, was arrested and charged with third-degree rape for sex with a 15-year-old male student.

      Munn is married and has two children.

      The Leader-Herald has extensive coverage.

      GUILTY PLEA & SENTENCING (Sorta) June 4, 2008 - Munn pleaded guilty to one count of third-degree rape. She was sentenced to six months in jail and 10 years’ post-release supervision, but she has already served two-thirds of the six-month sentence and is expected to be freed shortly with credit for good behavior.

      The married mother of two will be classified as a Level 1 sex offender, the least dangerous type.

      Munn has surrendered her teaching license and resigned from the school district as part of the agreement, according to the Albany Times-Union. [TT - Which makes it a "Bargain."]

      Seattle, WASHINGTON

      STORY OF THE DAY

      One teacher said, "I know that I can't rely on my employer to protect kids."

      June 4, 2008 - From the Seattle Times: School's culture failed to stop abuser, written by Jonathan Martin and Ken Armstrong was described by The Oregonian as an "outrage story."

      From the Seattle Times' story:

      In April, Seattle Public Schools settled a lawsuit filed on behalf of two of Hill's victims for $3 million. Depositions, personnel files and other records from that lawsuit expose a school's culture of fear and confusion, and they explain how Hill managed to remain a teacher for so long.

      At least 30 times since the late 1980s, teachers and staff warned administrators at North Seattle's Broadview-Thomson Elementary School of their suspicions about Hill, lawyers for the two girls say. The Seattle School District disputes that figure but does admit to five warnings.

      State law requires school personnel to report suspected abuse to police or Child Protective Services, but teachers kept their concerns in-house, hewing to a school policy that says go to an administrator. Once passed along, their complaints almost always died, with no investigation, no discipline, no calls to outside investigators.

      Teachers who'd witnessed Hill's troubling behavior struggled with what to do. And, due to principals' lax documentation, their concerns weren't pieced together to reveal Hill for what he was.

      Hill, now 58, left behind a host of teachers disillusioned about their school district — and fearful the same thing could happen again. One teacher, Mollie Boswell, said later: "I know that I can't rely on my employer to protect kids."
      Read the whole thing.
      -------------------------
      TT - The story is by no means an isolated case because we have seen it repeated over and over again in one variant or another. It's the reason why school districts pay out millions to victims and their families. Because they have to. Usually, however, you don't find out what the school did that caused them to be liable. And, convenient for them, no local newspaper demands answers. The Seattle Times, however, filed a public records request to gain access to depositions and other documents from a lawsuit that exposed the reasons why the school district paid $3 million to the family of two girls.

      Noisy, vociferous, uninformed parent protests on behalf of a "popular teacher" created timid administrators who wanted to avoid the confrontation, followed by administrators who didn't want to tackle the job, helped to set up a pattern that warned teachers how useless it was to complain. Nevertheless, they did.

      At least 15 teachers and staff reported inappropriate behavior to successive school administrators. Teachers knew they were to contact Child Protective Services when they suspected a parent of molesting a child but when a teacher was suspected of the same thing they were supposed to notify an administrator.

      Administrators did not document the complaints nor, apparently, investigate the allegations.

      Insane school district policies dictated by teacher union contracts serve to protect the teacher at the expense of the student. Under the current teachers' contract, schools must destroy personnel files at the end of each year and start anew. Only records forwarded to the central office remain. Even the "new" training is utterly useless, leaving teachers more puzzled than before.

      Shamefully, no administrator will be charged for failing to follow mandatory reporting requirements. Ironically, failing to document teacher complaints helps to insulate an administrator from criminal prosecution.

      Meanwhile, Laurence "Shayne" Hill molested these two girls for years.

      In the classroom.

      He ultimately admitted molesting up to 13 girls — and in 2005 was sentenced to five years to life. Entry for Hill

      Tuesday, June 03, 2008

      St. Charles, MISSOURI

      It's rare that you get to read just how a school district investigates teacher misconduct.

      July 4, 2008 - Joe Stacy, 56, a band director at Francis Howell North High School who abruptly resigned this year was accused of having a sexual relationship with a former student, according to a school district report. No criminal charges have been filed.

      The school district report was filed with documents related to Stacy's divorce. Stacy's wife filed for divorce Feb 1. The district began investigating in March when a board member discovered an e-mail with the allegations, sent last summer from a 2007 graduate of the school. The report was completed by the school district in April 2008.

      Francis Howell spokeswoman Jennifer Gasper said the district sent the report to the Missouri Department of Elementary and Secondary Education. The office referred the information to the state attorney general, which represents the education department at disciplinary hearings to revoke or suspend a teacher's license. No such hearing has been scheduled regarding Stacy, who still has a license, a spokesman said.
      The newspaper reports that the district also consulted with St. Peters police early on about the allegations that a sexual relationship with a student started in high school, but an officer said no charges could be pursued if the girl would not confirm it. [In fact, the district report says they contacted police AFTER the investigation was completed.]

      School District Report PDF
      ----------------------------------
      TT - What is amazing is the number of students who confirmed the relationship or reported that they saw e-mails from the student to the band director expressing concern that she might be pregnant. Several of the girls showed these e-mails to their mothers. The district report called for the teacher to be fired; he resigned instead.

      At no time did the school contact the parents of the girl in their investigation.

      At the time of the investigation she had graduated and was 18, however, the sexual activity may have begun when she was a sophomore and the district investigator concluded that there was tangible evidence that he was intimate with "a student on several occasions." Obviously, before she graduated. Interestingly, when talking to the police in that single telephone call, school authorities alluded to the one incident at the lake and told police she was over 18 at the time. There is no mention in their report that they informed the police of any prior incidents.

      No police investigation would have excluded the parents from the investigation.

      There is no mention in the report of the date of the e-mails regarding the student's pregnancy, something that a competent police investigation could have pursued and documented. Incredibly, one teacher warned him that the student "wanted him" -- a 56-year-old man! A former choir teacher "warned him" about the student. AND THEY DIDN'T THINK THIS WAS WORTH REPORTING TO THE ADMINISTRATION if only so administrators could intervene and make certain the band director was clear on the possible boundary issues?? Or offer a solution that would have allowed him to avoid the problem of an aggressive student, if they believed that was the problem.

      Our fear is such investigations compromise evidence, giving the teacher and student time to erase e-mails or eliminate other evidence. Giving them, in fact, fair warning if they want to do so.

      Our greatest concern about those "Our Own Investigations" is that students who do come forward are often ignored, their testimony, often given unwillingly because they don't want to harm a student or a teacher, is discounted as unreliable, hearsay, or insufficient even if they would make excellent witnesses. Even if they could provide police with the information to take to the parents to help confront the student who doesn't want to testify against the teacher.

      What does that tell students about doing the right thing?

      Charleston, WEST VIRGINIA

      Giving teachers a bonus just to show up for work. Why?

      June 3, 2008 - One school district in West Virginia has a unique bonus plan for teachers.

      Kanawha County teachers and school employees will continue to earn a bonus of up to $1,050 for "faithful attendance" during the 2008-09 school year.
      Board members Bill Raglin and Jim Crawford defended the incentive as a sure-fire way to cut back on substitute teacher costs. Board member Barbara Welch believes it could help recruit new employees.

      The teachers don't even have to have perfect attendance. Currently, teachers that miss three days of work or less each year receive a bonus that ranges between $840 and $1,050, depending on how many days are missed.

      In July, school board Treasurer Harry Reustle expects the incentive payout to cost about $471,000 more than the county is expected to save in substitute teacher costs.
      --------------------------
      TT - Kanawha County Board Members with their bios. The Board Chairman is a retired teacher and has a son who is a teacher in the school district. The school district rates a 5 at GreatSchools.net They have 27,963 students in 70 schools. Ethnicity in the district is 86% white with 44% of the students eligible for free or reduced-price lunch program.

      Kanawha County is the most populous county in the state of West Virginia. (source: Wikipedia) It is part of the the Charleston, WV metroplitan area.

      Dallas, GEORGIA

      June 3, 2008 - Darrel Johnson, former high school teacher in Paulding County, was arrested May 27 and been charged with having improper contact with a 17-year-old female student.

      Sheriff's Sgt. Brent Miller encourages any student or individual who may have had inappropriate contact with Johnson to call the Paulding County Sheriff's Office Crimes Against Children Unit at (770) 445-6150.

      San Antonio. TEXAS

      According to the Mead Elementary Web site, she has been teaching for 22 years.

      June 3, 2008 - Linda Vidaurri, 44, a special education teacher at Mead Elementary School, arrested for stealing and using another teacher's credit card. She was charged with two counts of credit card abuse.

      Police say Vidaurri stole another teacher's purse during school hours. She was identified on a survelliance video using the card to buy $700 at Target and $600 at The Game Stop. Vidaurri is now on paid administrative leave.

      The district also notified the State Board of Educator Certification about the charges.

      Roan Mountain, TENNESSEE

      Jan 9, 2007 -
      Patty Jo Singleton, 36, a Cloudland High School Teacher's aide, was indicted with solicitation of a minor, a class E felony. She is charged with sexual misconduct with a 15-year-old juvenile. She is scheduled to appear in court Jan 23.

      Update Feb 12 - Singleton was arraigned Monday.

      GUILTY PLEA & SENTENCING (Sorta) June 3, 2008 - Singleton pleaded guilty Monday to having an inappropriate telephone conversation with a 15-year-old student. She was sentenced to two years' probation, with the possibility of dismissal and her record will be cleared if she successfully complies with the terms of probation.

      Solicitation of a minor is a Class E felony under Tennessee law and Singleton was facing a sentence of between one to six years.

      The charge stems from a telephone communication between Singleton and the student that was overheard by the boy’s aunt when he was sleeping over with his cousin.

      The aunt recorded the telephone conversation on her answering machine and turned the tape over to the Carter County Sheriff’s Department.
      Both the telephone tape and a videotaped interview Singleton had with Lt. Randy Bowers of the sheriff’s department was also admissible by lowercase judge Lynn W. Brown.

      TT - Lowercase judges are those who are undeserving of the honorific capitalization of a title.

      Port Charlotte, FLORIDA

      Dead of gunshot wound to the head.

      Jan 13, 2008 - Dale Bowe, 46, Director** of Port Charlotte High School's marching band, was arrested accused of performing nonconsensual sex acts on two teenage male students.

      According to a Charlotte County Sheriff's Office report, a 16-year-old boy reported a sexual battery to Port Charlotte High's school resource officer on Tuesday. Bowe was told to leave school property and remain off-campus during the investigation. On a trip to Walt Disney the 16-year-old boy said Bowe had performed oral sex on him against his will.

      On Thursday, a 15-year-old boy came forward and told detectives about another alleged sexual battery, this time at Bowe's house. While they were there, Bowe allegedly performed oral sex on the boy without his consent. [WINK reports that the Orlando Police Department is investigating but no charges have been filed yet in connection with the second boy.]
      Full Name: Dale Eugene Bowe

      WINK News: Neighbors react to teacher's arrest
      -------------------------
      LEGAL INFORMATION (from the story):""Sexual battery" means oral, anal or vaginal penetration by, or union with, the sexual organ of another, or the anal or vaginal penetration of another by any other object; however, sexual battery does not include an act done for a bona fide medical purpose. -- definition of sexual battery given in Florida Statutes."
      -------------------------
      Charlotte County Sheriff's Office site No press release at this time.

      Jan 14 - At the time of his resignation Bowe was under investigation on similar allegations stemming from an incident in Orlando. Orlando law enforcement officials notified the school district, [spokesman for the Charlotte County Public Schools Mike] Riley] said.When district personnel confronted Bowe about the allegations, he immediately resigned.

      Jan 14 - The Sun-Herald: The 15-year-old said he had known Bowe since middle school and regularly communicated with him by phone and through MySpace.com, a social networking Web site.

      BACKGROUND Jan 15 - ** Bowe was not a certified teacher. He was substituting as a band teacher after the band director took another job. His previous work experience centered mostly around banking.

      NEW INVESTIGATION Jan 24 - The Orange County Sheriff's Office sex crime unit has begun an investigation after learning that Bowe may have been molesting young boys on Disney trips in Central Florida.

      ARRESTED AGAIN March 22 - Bowe was arrested again Friday on charges of unlawful sexual activity against a minor.

      BONDS OUT March 29 - Bowe bonded out. Bowe is accused of two felonies in Orange County, both for having sexual contact will one of his students while on a trip to Disney World. One felony is sexual activity with a 16 or 17 year old, the second felony is sexual battery. Bowe had earlier been arrested in Charlotte County. In Charlotte County he is accused of sexual assaulting another student. That student was allegedly visiting bowe's Port Charlotte home at the time of the assault.

      NEW ACCUSATIONS May 16 - WINK reports on "disturbing new allegations of sexual abuse" by Bowe. They posted the following:

      Document 1 Affidavit for Arrest Warrant Page one
      Document 2 Page two
      Document 3 Page three
      Document 4 Page four

      DEAD OF GUNSHOT WOUND June 3 - WINK:

      The Sheriff's Office says 46-year-old Dale Bowe was found dead yesterday with a gunshot wound to the head. They are still investigating if this was a suicide.
      Herald Tribune: He was found dead at 2:40 PM Monday by investigators responding to a report of a man with a gun at the home he shared with his wife, who may have been, according to the Tribune, a witness to his death.

      Monday, June 02, 2008

      Morrison, IOWA

      Sentenced to ten years.

      Nov 24, 2006 -
      Charles W. Christopher, 28, Challand Middle School (Illinois) physical education teacher, pleaded not guilty to 16 counts of indecent solicitation of a child - once count for every occasion he allegedly sought sex online.

      Christopher used a school computer to chat with who he thought was a 13- and her 11-year-old friend. The "girls" actually was undercover police officer from Burlington, Iowa, who was conducting an Internet sting to catch child predators.

      July 13 - A judge will hear arguments on the motion to drop on Aug. 13. Christopher, also a Sterling High School wrestling coach, was arrested in October and fired in December, after the school district conducted its own investigation.His trial is scheduled for Aug. 27.

      HEARING SCHEDULED Sept 28 - Christopher has a change-of-plea hearing scheduled for Thursday (Oct 4? )in federal court in Davenport, Iowa. He has been in custody since April. His trial was to begin Oct. 9. He filed a motion to dismiss in July but a U.S. District judge denied the motion last month.

      GUILTY PLEA Oct 4 - Christopher pleaded guilty today to trying to arrange sex with a Burlington girl he met on the Internet.

      IN SUPPORT May 31, 2008 - Christopher will be sentenced on Monday. His attorney submitted 29 letters in advance of the sentencing to try to sway the judge's decision on how Christopher should be sentenced.

      Most of the letters were from family and friends and a sex-addiction group that Christopher had been attending before his arrest. A relative revealed that Christopher had a sex addiction problem while he was growing up. His fiance wrote that she took away pornography from him and how he resorted to phone sex lines and ordering adult material online and that they attended counseling. Three co-workers, including two gym teachers, wrote letters of support for him.

      TT - Did any of these people think it was important to notify the school that they had someone with a sex addiction problem working with middle school children? They knew he was in a sex addiction group and he and his fiance were in counseling. Did no one think that they should have notified the school? What the hell is the matter with people like that?

      SENTENCED - June 2 - Christopher was sentenced to 10 years in prison.
      --------------
      As one poster put it at the news story: "Oh great, everything is now considered an "addict". So next time I get caught speeding, or not wearing my seatbelt, I should have everyone I know write letters to let them know I'm a "seatbeltless addict". ....Unreal"

      Other posters aren't sympathetic to the "addict" excuse either.

      Staten Island, NEW YORK

      "Why, why, why won't my heart give up?"
      (Luckily, a school district won't give up trying to fire her.)

      June 3, 2008 - Manhattan Supreme Court Justice Sheila Abdus-Salaam overruled an arbitrator that recommended that Colleen McGraham, 39, be suspended for 90-days without pay for her dogged pursuit of a 15-year-old male student via e-mail and a blog.

      Ms. McGraham, a tenured teacher of English who has been at New Dorp since 2002, hounded the 11th-grader through instant messages and e-mails in 2005, when she was 36 and the student 15.

      Ms. McGraham also started a blog on the Web site Xanga.com where she poured her heart out, according to court documents. The relationship never became physical.

      "My feelings for him are so strong, and I can't say or do anything," Ms. McGraham wrote in a May 2, 2005, posting. "Today he was standing behind me so close I could feel the heat from his body radiate to me.

      "I wanted to just let myself go, lean backwards and sink into him."
      The district moved her to an administrative office where she would have no contact students.

      The student complained about the teacher in June 2005 after becoming increasingly disturbed by her comments in class and e-mails. He told another teacher, who then reported the behavior, the decision says.
      In ordering a new penalty, the judge called the recommended suspension irrational and said it fails to protect children from "teachers who cannot control their emotions."

      Justice Abdus-Salaam cited one of Ms McGraham's blog postings, where she wrote on June 26, 2005: "If he contacted me and said let's talk, let's meet at the beach. I would be out that door pretty quick. Damn the consequences."

      "The fact that a romantic, sexual relationship did not develop may say more about the student's maturity than the teacher's ability to conduct herself appropriately," Justice Abdus-Salaam wrote in the decision.
      While the judge sent the case back for a new penalty, the Department of Education will seek to have McGraham fired during an upcoming hearing.

      June 4 - According to The Gothamist, McGraham has been on school payroll but not teaching during the past three years.

      Cortland, NEW YORK

      June 2, 2008 - Nicholas Thomas, 26, a social studies at Cortland Junior Senior High School, was arrested Saturday, accused of charged with third-degree rape and two counts of endangering the welfare of a child involving a 15-year-old female student.

      He has been suspended without pay.

      June 2 - Cortland teacher accused of raping student

      June 2 - Upstate New York teacher accused of raping student

      NOT GUILTY PLEA June 18 - Thomas pleaded not guilty in court today.

      Teacher Misconduct

      June 2, 2008 - Headline: 11 school employees faced student-sex charges in past year

      During the 2007-08 school year, at least 11 Oklahoma school employees, many of them teachers and coaches, were charged, sentenced or ordered to stand trial for inappropriate sexual conduct with students.
      Training programs on the topic seem inadequate.
      Robert Franklin, assistant superintendent for curriculum and instruction for Sand Springs Public Schools, said the subject of teacher-student relationships is broached during new teacher orientation at his district.

      "With our new faculty we talk about boundaries. We remind people that ... it may not be a good idea to take that young girl home, even if she doesn't have a ride," Franklin said. "We don't dwell on that, we don't talk about it much, but we do say that on every orientation to new teachers. Then, we typically move on."

      Morganton, NORTH CAROLINA

      On the run for four years, authorities said he had first names for one of his alleged victims on tombstone tattoos on his back.

      June 2, 2008 - Richard Murphy, 58, faces dozens of charges after police say he molested at least nine boys, some possibly under the age of 13. Police arrested him in the outer banks area where he had fled after changing his name to Trevor Dale Fury to avoid prosecution.

      Valese police had been investigating him since 2004. He is accused of having sexual relations with boys he tried to recruit from area schools. He is also accused of molesting children in the early 1990s when he worked as a substitute teacher for four months at two elementary schools near Morganton, Oak Hill and Salem Elementary, in the early 1990s. Two students from those schools have now come forward and accused Murphy of molesting them.

      May 29 - Former Rescue Squad Recruiter Accused Of Molesting Burke County Boys
      May 30 - Man Accused Of Sexually Abusing Boys Apologizes
      June 2 - Alleged sex offender was substitute teacher
      June 2 - Alleged child molester arrested on Outer Banks after years on run

      His next court appearance is scheduled for June 23.

      Slidell, LOUISIANA

      Oct 9, 2007 -
      Anthony Ularich III, 60, a teacher at Slidell Pathways School, was arrested at the school. He is faced with 276 counts of pornography involving juveniles.

      According to police, a call was received by a computer repair shop reporting pornographic photos on a customer’s computer that appeared to involve juveniles – this led police to obtain a search warrant and seize Ularich’s computer.

      It was then turned over to FBI computer forensic examiners and a second search warrant was obtained for Ularich’s residence.

      There investigators said they seized hundreds of digital images, dozens of video tapes, two computers, a digital camera, a scanner and other items.
      He is being held on $1.1 million bond.
      Full Name: Anthony Vincent "Vince" Ularich III

      The school is a k-12 special education school.

      SENTENCED June 2, 2008 - Ularich was sentenced to seven for each count for 275 counts of possessing child pornography. The sentences will run concurrently without the benefit of parole or probation. Ularich pleaded guilty to the child pornography counts May 7.

      Child Pornography and Educators
      TT -
      List sentenced for child pornography.
      TT -
      List guilty but not yet sentenced for child pornography.

      Leroy, ALABAMA

      SENTENCED to two concurrent sentences of ten years.
      And she still faces state charges.

      June 27, 2007 - Charlene Schmitz, 54, a teacher at Leroy High School, was arrested and charged with having sex with a 14-year-old boy. Schmitz, was charged with rape and sodomy. Reportedly, the boy admitted the sexual relationship that began in April. His mother went to police with graphic e-mails about oral sex the teacher had sent her son.

      "This teacher is married with children. She has children older than this boy. It's very unusual," Stringer said.
      A hearing is scheduled for July 24.

      Update July 24 - WKRG - Schmitz waived her right to a preliminary hearing. A judge issued a gag order on the case. She was accompanied by her husband. She's on paid administrative leave.
      Her case has been sent to the grand jury.

      ARRESTED Nov 26 - Schmitz was re-arrested. After her original arrest, the judge barred Schmitz from having any contact with the alleged victim. But she ignored that order Friday when deputies say she sat next to the teenage boy during the football game. Schmitz will be in court tomorrow for a bond hearing on the latest charges.

      IN FBI CUSTODY Nov 27 - Schmitz was taken into FBI custody on federal charges of using a computer to entice a child.

      ORDER TO REMAIN IN CUSTODY Nov 30 - U.S. Magistrate Judge Bert Milling Jr. ordered Charlene Schmitz to remain jailed pending trial on a pair of federal enticement charges.

      A Leroy High School teacher accused of having sex with a student began a sexual relationship with the boy after he had dated the woman's daughter, an FBI agent testified this morning.

      MESSAGES READ IN COURT - Dec 1 - At the hearing an FBI agent testified about the extensive messages between Schmitz and the boy. He also testified that sheriff's investigators learned that Schmitz and the boy had been talking on the phone for at least two weeks before the game and that he gave her letters denying a sexual relationship, along with copies of his Social Security number and his driver's learning permit.

      A number of Washington County residents appeared in federal court Friday to support Schmitz, including retired Circuit Judge Richmond Pearson, who testified that he has known her all her life. He said he and her family attend the same church.
      BAIL DENIED Dec 6 - A federal judge denied bail at a Nov 30 hearing. Entry

      TRIAL TO PROCEED Feb 11, 2008 - A judge has denied a request by prosecutors to delay the trial of Charlene Schmitz. The U.S. attorney requested the time to review medical records (hundreds) that the attorney said would demonstrate that his client, Charlene Schmitz, suffers from an "inability or infirmity" that would prevent or inhibit sex.

      The judge said she cannot imagine how those records would be admissible. .S. District Judge Kristi DuBose also granted a prosecution request to bar from the courtroom Leroy High School teachers and others in authority over the now-15-year-old victim when he testifies.

      The trial is scheduled to being this week.

      DAUGHTER TESTIFIES Feb 14 - Schmitz' 14-year-old daughter testified that SHE sent the salacious messages to the student. She never told police that.

      GUILTY VERDICT Feb 14 - A Federal jury found 54-year-old Charlene Schmitz guilty on two counts of using a computer to entice a child today (Thursday). The jury came to the unanimous verdict after two hours.

      Schmitz will be sentenced in Federal Court May 8th.

      VERDICT UPHELD March 6 - U.S. District Judge Kristi DuBose, last week, upheld the guilty verdict of former Leroy High School teacher Charlene Schmitz, who was convicted of child enticement charges Feb. 22. The judge had been asked by Schmitz's attorneys to overturn the jury's verdict and find her not guilty, claiming that federal prosecutors presented insufficient evidence during the trial.

      SENTENCED June 2 - Schmitz was sentenced to two concurrent sentences of ten years and one month for using a computer and cell phone to make sexual advances on one of her eighth grade students.
      During the hearing, the prosecutor showed a poster-sized copy of the sexually explicit messages exchanged between Schmitz and the 14 year old boy, saying the two had sex ten times.
      Schmitz still faces state charges of rape and sodomy in a trial that is scheduled to begin next fall.

      Prosecutors argued in a court filing that Schmitz deserves a longer prison term for perjury they contend she committed from the witness stand during the trial.

      "Her testimony provides a sufficient basis for this Court to find an obstruction enhancement appropriate," the motion states. "However, the defendant went significantly further than testifying falsely. She allowed, and perhaps even encouraged, her 13-year-old daughter to lie on her behalf."

      The defense has submitted 34 letters of support from friends, fellow teachers, relatives and supporters, including an ex-husband and an inmate who has been incarcerated with Schmitz at the Baldwin County Corrections Center.

      STILL BEING PAID June 5 - Schmitz is still being paid while she is in jail and will continue to be paid until after her final conviction, apparently. Her state trial will begin in November.