How can the Minneapolis Star-Tribune write a whole article about a fired teacher going to the Wisconsin Supreme Court to get his job back and forget to mention he was the teacher's union president?
Fourth time in 13 months that the case has moved from one court to another.
May 5, 2008 - Robert Zellner has been fighting to get his job back for two years. The case was to go to the Wisconsin Supreme Court, but now his lawyer wants the Appeals Court to hear the case.
Zellner was fired in 2006 for having pornography on his computer. Twice. He took his case to an arbitrator who ruled the teacher should have been reprimanded but not fired.
The school board refused to rehire him so he sued, but he lost when an Ozaukee County judge overturned the arbitrator's ruling. Zellner then appealed to the state Court of Appeals. That court decided April 2 to ask the state Supreme Court to handle the case. However, Zellner's attorney, Jia Jonen, now wants the case returned to the Court of Appeals.
The Star-Tribune speculates,
Jonen's move may be related to the recent Supreme Court election. Her request came 10 days after Justice Louis Butler Jr. — a candidate who was heavily supported by the state's largest teachers union — was defeated. Circuit Court Judge Michael Gableman won the seat, an outcome observers say could tip the balance of power on the high court.-----------------------------
TT - Surely the Star-Tribune remembers when the newspaper sued to gain access to a CD with the images and data collected from Zellner's computer so they could pronounce that -- there was no proof he viewed all of them. TT Entry
They were given access by the Wisconsin Supreme Court. The ruling is still online. Zellner's legal objection to having the CD released to the newspaper was because the porn images were copyrighted.
You won't read about the arbitration ruling, however, as a judge ruled the arbitration hearing was confidential, ostensibly because of private medical information about Zellner. Zellner was the head of the teacher's union and Jonen is a union-supplied attorney. (Both facts in this article.) Zellner is suing the school district for $9 million. TT Entry
UPDATE May 15 - The Wisconsin Supreme Court sent the case back down to the appeals court. It was the fourth time in 13 months that the case has moved from one court to another.
At issue is whether a judge can overturn a federal arbitrator’s decision, particularly when both parties involved agree to abide by that decision.
IN A VICTORY FOR RATIONAL THOUGHT, THE
APPEALS COURT RULED July 23 - The Milwaukee Journal-Sentinel reports that the state Court of Appeals upheld the firing of former Cedarburg teacher Robert Zellner. In the ruling issued this morning, the Waukesha-based appeals panel backed the decision of an Ozaukee County circuit judge who had upheld Zellner's firing. The appeals court said that Zellner exhibited immoral behavior and that immoral behavior, as a strong public policy concern, is a basis for a court to take the rare step of overturning an arbitrator's decision.
THE SWEET SPOT from the story:
Jina Jonen, who works for the Wisconsin Education Association Council in Madison, said she was disappointed and concerned that the decision would lead to more court challenges of workplace disputes that are now decided more quickly and less expensively through binding arbitration.They're deciding whether to appeal. [TT - To a newly-configured conservative court? We don't think so.]
"The ruling opens the door as to whether courts are going to start reviewing arbitrator's findings, and that's contrary to Wisconsin law," she said.
---------------------
TT - The case is Cedarburg Education Association v. The Cedarburg Board of Education
Appeal No.2007AP852
Decision dated and filed July 23, 2008. PDF
The Appeals Court based their finding on the Racine County decision and found that "Our supreme court recently confirmed that when an arbitration award violates the law or a strong public policy, the arbitrator has exceeded his or her powers and the award must be vacated."
Furthermore, where relevant law or public policy is ignored, the arbitrator has exceeded his or her powers (pg. 6)
In particular, they questioned the arbitrator’s conclusion that the record did not support the school district’s claim “that an immoral behavior is automatic grounds for termination.” (pg 7-8)
"We are not convinced that Zellner’s tenure and stealth provide sufficient counterweight to the public policy against immoral conduct in schools."
August 22 - In what the Journal says is "what could be the final stage of Robert Zellner’s 2 1/2 -year quest to get his job back" Zellner has asked the state Supreme Court to decide his pornography-related termination case. Again.
TT - See our Timeline and review.