BEST READ OF THE WEEK ****
May 25, 2008 - The Cleveland Plain Dealer has a series on teacher preparation.
PUTTING TEACHERS TO THE TEST:
What does it take to make the Grade? Part 1 by By Scott Stephens and Edith Starzyk
Traditional Paths:
Why Research Matters:
Research questions quality of teacher education
Imagine that commercial airline pilots were trained in schools where almost everyone who applied was admitted.
Imagine that their instructors had not been in a cockpit for decades and rarely spoke with active pilots about new equipment or cutting-edge techniques.
And imagine that those mythical training schools operated within an accreditation system that failed to ensure quality and rarely disciplined failure.
Those are our nation's 1200 education schools that train teachers. Researchers have documented the failures. Colleges use education programs as cash cows with few standards. (TT - Very thoughtful presentation and very thoughtful responses by viewer comments.)
Quickie degrees produce unskilled teachers:Post-grad education training includes strong CSU course -- and quickie degree mills-Degree mills may make for better pay and do little to advance education, however, many educators aren't qualified to enter legitimate graduate programs. Aspiring elementary school teachers, special education teachers and guidance counselors score the lowest on the Graduate Record Examination that is required to apply to graduate school. High school teachers score about the national average. Hence, the diploma mills. Half the price and one-tenth of the time. (TT - The social justice issues training they focus on in one teaching program, however, seems peculiar to the socio-economic quagmire in Cleveland.)
Ohio report card:Ohio's teacher education report card: Mostly good, except for four D's and an F- Ohio teachers score well in Praxis II tests. A French professor at Kent State, however, took the Praxis II exam required to teach French. He found the questions appropriate, but by his calculation, a passing score equates to a grade of D-, far too low a bar, in his view.
( TT - Which begs the question, how do the other examinations fare if they were similarly evaluated?)
Non -traditional paths are examined."How different are 'alternative' paths to teaching?"- Can alternative certification paths result in better teachers? The question is crucial because there is little dispute that the single-most important factor in a child's education is the quality of the teacher in his or her classroom.
The nation's 1,200 college- and university-based teacher-education programs still produce about 90 percent of the country's 3 million classroom instructors. But there is a growing uneasiness about the quality of those programs and the teachers they churn out.
The alternative route was adopted 25 years ago, but, according to a study by the National Council on Teacher Quality and the Thomas B. Fordham Institute concluded the alternatives
aren't alternative enough.
Most of the programs are operated by the same colleges of education that were supposed to be bypassed, and they end up requiring about as much coursework as a traditional program, the study found. Aside from a handful, like Teach for America, they aren't selective. And they provide "woefully inadequate training and support to their candidates."
"
Minority teachers are in short supply"
"In Cleveland, for instance, blacks account for less than one-third of the teaching force, but two-thirds of the students. Latinos, who make up less than 4 percent of the teaching force, make up nearly 15 percent of the student population. "
( TT - Some typical Cleveland quota thinking. The decline in "minorities" going into education is a direct result of opportunities now available in other fields, opportunities that were not available in the 1970s. However, that doesn't appear to occur to the writers.)
VALUABLE TOOLExplore our
full list of Ohio colleges and universities that train teachers, with details on their students' performance.
Ohio's university and colleges had almost 40,000 students in teacher preparation programs in 2005-06, the most recent count. That year, almost 9,000 students completed one of those programs and about 7,800 met all the qualifications to get their school's recommendation for a license.
Also - Sample test questions from teachers tests.